I have been a forumer since late 2022, and have never found it out

Also, isn't Connecting to the Physical World less active?

glitcX wrote:

I have been a forumer since late 2022, and have never found it out

Also, isn't Connecting to the Physical World less active?

It has more pages, though. Besides, logically, what forum would that be combined with?

glitcX wrote:

I have been a forumer since late 2022, and have never found it out

Also, isn't Connecting to the Physical World less active?

Unlike OSP, CttPW actually has a use. Most of what would be discussed in OSP already winds up in ATs- and I think even that's a minority- most of the people working on wind up at GitHub anyways because they either 1) don't have a Scratch account, and don't want to make one, 2) don't know about the forums, or 3) don't want to post somewhere where it won't be noticed anyways when they could just make an issue or PR.

bump

support, i forgot that forum even existed

i support, the foss forum's a good idea but it's rarely used (most little kiddies don't have github, scratch)
edited because i forgot to add my signature support :skull:

It’s pretty much dead, and I feel like it can be integrated within Advanced Topics.

No support, just because it is dead doesn’t mean nobody would find it useful.
The Norwegian and Catalan forums are all dead too, but somebody might want to post a topic there because they don’t know English very well and they want their questions answered

some other languages subforums are also dead, yet they’re there
besides, the latest non-scratch-team posts are still in this month, which is still more decently active than some other languages subforums

GratefulGamer9398233 wrote:

but somebody might want to post a topic there because they don’t know English very well and they want their questions answered

tbh they’d just jump straight to questions about scratch these days

kat-coder wrote:

No support. We should still have a forum to discuss open source projects.

You'd be able to do this in Advanced Topics still. The original poster also mentioned that the forum could be closed, with all of the topics moved to Advanced Topics.

I made a duplicate topic oopsies
anyways yeah because almost everything there can also exist in at

What does that topic do?

VedanshS933 wrote:

What does that topic do?

Do you mean the Open Source Projects forum, or this topic?
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/383437/

medians wrote:

VedanshS933 wrote:

What does that topic do?

Do you mean the Open Source Projects forum, or this topic?
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/383437/

The forum.

No Support - I don’t support your suggestion for the following reasons:

- They are also questions about them
- TubroWarp is an example of them
- Also look at the list

Here’s the list of the latest topics in that forum: (sorted by the most recent topic bump)

Is it allowed to share a clone of Scratch api? by _0xfffrog- (New Posts)
PMMP (Playful Mathematicians Math Playground) by MandelbrotOS (New Posts)
Why on the KDE Store when I install “Scratch” It installs scratch 1.0? by -Syntax01- (New Posts)
Chromium Scratch Apps? by babmv (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
turbowarp list archiving. by code_line (New Posts)
2 298 Feb. 11, 2025 18:29:04 by T_cat9000_2
What open source projects are! by MagentaDude1359 (New Posts)
Scratch… in Turbowarp? by Knaginb7438 (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
Open source projects? What? by TheOpalofTopaz (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
Where in scratch-www are the messages? by alboxer2000 (New Posts)
Why is the Scratchr2 repo private? by ilikecereal1 (CLOSED TOPIC)
TI-84 Support For Scratch by undeterminstic (New Posts)
What's open source? by Meme_master235 (New Posts)
why this exists?? by REALchipflake (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
6 419 Dec. 24, 2024 16:30:47 by Rain68
20 cloud vars in one project by isaiah2011train (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
TurboWarp project_url parameter by georgek0 (New Posts)
AI on Scratch by kRxZy_kRxZy (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
Scratch Coding by Euzcom (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
Changelog : Scratch Update History by apple502j (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
scratch 4.0 isn't coming out by kRxZy_kRxZy (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)
4.0 is never coming out by kRxZy_kRxZy (New Posts) (CLOSED TOPIC)

(Most of them are closed anyways)

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

- They are also questions about them

Most of which would be fine in Advanced Topics or Developing Scratch Extensions anyways

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

- TubroWarp is an example of them

Actually it isn't (Scratch mod-related topics go in ATs, not OSP- OSP is really for the ST's open source projects), and TurboWarp's topic is in ATs.

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

Is it allowed to share a clone of Scratch api? by _0xfffrog- (New Posts)

Would be fine in ATs or even QaS

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

PMMP (Playful Mathematicians Math Playground) by MandelbrotOS (New Posts)

Shouldn't be there- might work better in ATs or TIMAC (maybe).

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

Why on the KDE Store when I install “Scratch” It installs scratch 1.0? by -Syntax01- (New Posts)

Should not be there- that would fit better in ATs or QaS.

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

turbowarp list archiving. by code_line (New Posts)

Should be in ATs- it's not related to OSP at all.

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

2 298 Feb. 11, 2025 18:29:04 by T_cat9000_2

Isn't a topic…?

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

What open source projects are! by MagentaDude1359 (New Posts)

Is a duplicate of a sticky

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

Where in scratch-www are the messages? by alboxer2000 (New Posts)

Finally, a topic that goes there

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

TI-84 Support For Scratch by undeterminstic (New Posts)

Should really be in ATs.

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

What's open source? by Meme_master235 (New Posts)

As a question about the forum, this is acceptable in this case, although it would also work in QaS.

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

6 419 Dec. 24, 2024 16:30:47 by Rain68

Is also not a topic…?

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

TurboWarp project_url parameter by georgek0 (New Posts)

Should really be in ATs (or even TurboWarp's topic), as it's not about the Scratch Team's open-source projects.

MyScratchedAccount wrote:

(Most of them are closed anyways)

And get very infrequent replies.

I will say that is OSP is closed down, an archive of it should be kept- close all the topics in it and prevent new ones from being made (kind of like Announcements).

bump
Most of the topics in OSP are still irrelevant.

For that reasoning, we should close the new scratcher's forum too.