Discuss Scratch

kittyje1
Scratcher
83 posts

What counts as an exact copy?

There is this person copying projects (again) and he changes one little bit that he doesn't credit (like music) and then passes the project off as his own. Does that count as “exact copy”?
MudkipKappa
Scratcher
500+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

Unfortunately, no, as that's a “meaningful change”.
However, if they don't credit the song, you could probably report them for that.
CST1229
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

MudkipKappa wrote:

(#2)
Unfortunately, no, as that's a “meaningful change”.
if he passes the project off as his own then that's also breaking the credit rule and is reportable!
MudkipKappa
Scratcher
500+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

CST1229 wrote:

MudkipKappa wrote:

(#2)
Unfortunately, no, as that's a “meaningful change”.
if he passes the project off as his own then that's also breaking the credit rule and is reportable!
Technically, no, as there's the remix watermark above the instructions.
bubgamer07
Scratcher
100+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

MudkipKappa wrote:

CST1229 wrote:

MudkipKappa wrote:

(#2)
Unfortunately, no, as that's a “meaningful change”.
if he passes the project off as his own then that's also breaking the credit rule and is reportable!
Technically, no, as there's the remix watermark above the instructions.
OP never said they were remixes though.
MagicCoder330
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

here's the run down. they must do all of these:
  1. credit you somehow (remix autocredit counts)
  2. make a change that is readily noticeable while playing the project
  3. don't intend to be disrespectful to you in their use
if one of those isn't followed you can report the project.

Last edited by MagicCoder330 (Jan. 28, 2025 19:36:32)

kittyje1
Scratcher
83 posts

What counts as an exact copy?

What if a single variable was changed, and it affects the project a lot, but the code or costumes isn't changed at all? Like when you progress through a game, save it to your computer, now the starting variable is different.
--ORI0N--
Scratcher
100+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

kittyje1 wrote:

What if a single variable was changed, and it affects the project a lot, but the code or costumes isn't changed at all? Like when you progress through a game, save it to your computer, now the starting variable is different.
If at least one noticeable change that affects how the project runs is made, it isn't considered an exact copy.

It is notable, however, if a user uploads a remix that removes all references to the original creator of the project, that doesn't count.
Cool_kid092
Scratcher
100+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

so an example of this would be he remixes appel, changes the bg music, then says that its tottaly his?
kittyje1
Scratcher
83 posts

What counts as an exact copy?

Cool_kid092 wrote:

so an example of this would be he remixes appel, changes the bg music, then says that its tottaly his?
Yes, but instead of pressing the remix button, he just downloads it and uploads it.
Voxalice
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

kittyje1 wrote:

(#10)

Cool_kid092 wrote:

so an example of this would be he remixes appel, changes the bg music, then says that its tottaly his?
Yes, but instead of pressing the remix button, he just downloads it and uploads it.
In that case, since his projects don't give any credit to the originals, you should report his projects.
Technically, his projects wouldn't be exact copies, but they would be uncredited copies of other people's projects, which isn't allowed on Scratch.

Last edited by Voxalice (Jan. 28, 2025 23:21:24)

TheAutocorrectingCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

MudkipKappa wrote:

CST1229 wrote:

MudkipKappa wrote:

(#2)
Unfortunately, no, as that's a “meaningful change”.
if he passes the project off as his own then that's also breaking the credit rule and is reportable!
Technically, no, as there's the remix watermark above the instructions.
You can always download a project and reupload it, but that's a different story…
Za-Chary
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

kittyje1 wrote:

There is this person copying projects (again) and he changes one little bit that he doesn't credit (like music) and then passes the project off as his own. Does that count as “exact copy”?
I should also mention that regardless of whether or not the project appears as a remix, the user should give credit to whoever originally made the music that was changed. If they don't, you can report it as uncredited material.
TacoMaster635
Scratcher
100+ posts

What counts as an exact copy?

kittyje1 wrote:

There is this person copying projects (again) and he changes one little bit that he doesn't credit (like music) and then passes the project off as his own. Does that count as “exact copy”?
They must give credit So you can report them

Powered by DjangoBB