Discuss Scratch

106809nes
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

I have been having an issue with Necroposting due to some bug that makes old topics go to the first page. I want to suggest that a date when it was made to the left of the Title. It would look something like this:
12/12/2023 - ExampleTitle by ExampleUser
or
December 12, 2023 - ExampleTItle by ExampleUser.

(Credits to Silverus (#3) for this part)
You could also do this:
November 12, 2023 - ExampleTitle by ExampleUser
11/12/2023 - ExampleTitle by ExampleUser

Last edited by 106809nes (Dec. 14, 2023 03:05:54)

GlitchedThrough
New Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Most users find said posts through googling, which sadly makes it tough to fight necroposts.
Sliverus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

I think that the date should be in red if it hasn't been posted on in a month, and is in a subforum other than Suggestions, TIMAC, or TIRAP. If the original poster is the one who bumps it up after a long time, the red will be removed as it's not a necropost.

Last edited by Sliverus (Dec. 13, 2023 01:49:24)

Xzillox
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Honestly I'm surprised they don't already have this. There are a lot of times I've nearly necroposted on accident so this would be a feature I would definitely like to have
106809nes
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Bump
106809nes
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Bump(Was off first page)
Scratchdev57
Scratcher
100+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Support.

Most people find posts from Google and Ocular, so this may not be that effective but anyway. Lots of people necropost. In QaS, I saw a post at the top which was from 6 years ago. It was answered, and the person who brought it up asked another question, different from the topic. This is quite annoying and common.

Sliverus wrote:

I think that the date should be in red if it hasn't been posted on in a month, and is in a subforum other than Suggestions, TIMAC, or TIRAP. If the original poster is the one who bumps it up after a long time, the red will be removed as it's not a necropost.
Show and Tell maybe?

Last edited by Scratchdev57 (Dec. 14, 2023 07:12:18)

Sliverus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Scratchdev57 wrote:

Show and Tell maybe?
Nah, I've got an alert for bumping another topic in Show and Tell.
106809nes
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

bump
106809nes
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Bump..(Off front page)
k7e
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

I still think that it should show the date in forums with “no necroposting”, like Suggestions. There's no point in not implementing it for forums like it.

Also, posting on an old suggestion that's, for instance, rejected, is still considered “necroposting” despite the fact that it is a suggestion.
Sliverus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

k7e wrote:

I still think that it should show the date in forums with “no necroposting”, like Suggestions. There's no point in not implementing it for forums like it.
I think that's a fair idea. Why not we combine ideas? I think that the date should be in red if it hasn't been posted on in a month, and is in a subforum other than Suggestions, TIMAC, or TIRAP. If the original poster is the one who bumps it up after a long time, the red will be removed as it's not a necropost. However, the date will never appear in red if the topic is one of the following: Announcements (for obvious reasons), Suggestions, TIMAC, TIRAP.

Additionally, I think dates should not appear in red if the topic is closed. Once the topic is reopened, it'll reset the time and turn red in one month.
k7e
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Sliverus wrote:

Additionally, I think dates should not appear in red if the topic is closed. Once the topic is reopened, it'll reset the time and turn red in one month.
That's fair, except for one point: why would the time reset if it was randomly reopened for some reason, as bumping it would still be a necropost?
Sliverus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

k7e wrote:

That's fair, except for one point: why would the time reset if it was randomly reopened for some reason, as bumping it would still be a necropost?
If a topic is incredibly active, then gets closed, then reopened, users might feel like they can't continue the discussion. We have to start over as if the conversation is just a continuation, picking back up where it left off. That's why I suggested a reset.

Last edited by Sliverus (Dec. 15, 2023 03:23:52)

k7e
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Sliverus wrote:

k7e wrote:

That's fair, except for one point: why would the time reset if it was randomly reopened for some reason, as bumping it would still be a necropost?
If a topic is incredibly active, then gets closed, then reopened, users might feel like they can't continue the discussion. We have to start over as if the conversation is just a continuation, picking back up where it left off. That's why I suggested a reset.
That's fair.
106809nes
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

BUmp
ajskateboarder
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

I bet the layout would become very cluttered if you were to include dates right next to topic titles/authors, so adding an extra column to the right would be good.

Although, as GlitchedThrough said, most people Google questions on Scratch and visit topics from there, so it might not help that much necropost wise. Maybe show the date on the search result as well?
106809nes
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

bump
FirstPrism12
Scratcher
100+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Support, I almost posted on a topic that was created in 2014 because some other Scrather decided to necropost and this would prevent that from happening to most Scratchers.
106809nes
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Add a date beside all topics in a̶̶n̶y̶ most subforums.

Powered by DjangoBB