The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

medians

HurricaneMitch1998M wrote:
Studio activity aged like milk, now (idk if it's my addon or what) I don't receive studio activity messages, and haven't for months

I think it’s a bug.

Medians bamboozled by 3.0 (version 3.0): https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/979822351/
hi875230163394: You're similar to valve in that you both hate a certain number…
Scratch 0.x, 1.x, 2.x, 3.x and LogoBlocks Archives
Bamboozlement: https://scratch.mit.edu/studios/33739789
Describe favorite topics: https://scratch.mit.edu/studios/35764610/
SP community won against Fandom :P
Years on internet: 16 (very close to 16)
medians: Oh god not this utc - 12 thing again..
Fun_Cupcake_i81: What, were you expecting not to see the utc - 12 thing again? THE UTC - 12 THIGN ALWAYS RETURNS. ALWAYS.
medians: I knew it would happen. I was the one who started it last year.
Fun_Cupcake_i81: Well then if you didn't want it back maybe you need to time travel to last year and fix that

Oh wait if you could time travel I think we all know exactly when you would go-
user1: That picture is from 2.0. Now he’s at my house and is my pet.
user2: But this is medians we're talking about, so “from 2.0” can mean the same thing as “from five seconds ago”.
Detect Scratch version here
My other accounts: @selfexplanatory @modesties @chaircard @fireflyhero @dividendyield @colloids @radians @skeuamorphism @dihectogon @anglebisector @aau- @EditBlockColors @AdamantOrb @MoongeistBeam @festively @Ampharos_ @straightforwardness @interchangeably
i trolled redcat LOL

if you see this

{what method did you use::control hat
answer on profile ::motion
} ::operators

;

k7e

cookieclickerer33 wrote:
k7e wrote:
Roblox888i wrote:
I think we should reject Bring back assets.scratch.mit.edu as a image host and bring back mobile forums
The first one is already rejected (and given how popular that assets was before, it should probably be added).
me on another topic wrote:
they didnt say “we wont be adding/removing this” they just said they didnt expect assets to be a highly used image host. and forgot that cross refencing the main sites filter with the fourms one would inadvertently block it

Then how come @Paddle2See closed the topic, and how come he stated that cubeupload “seems like what folks should be using”?

@mythoslore was so much more obvious than @spookily

RobotChickens

medians wrote:
(#7887)
HurricaneMitch1998M wrote:
Studio activity aged like milk, now (idk if it's my addon or what) I don't receive studio activity messages, and haven't for months
I think it’s a bug.

There is a dedicated discussion about it here :-)

k7e wrote:
(#7888)
Then how come @Paddle2See closed the topic, and how come he stated that cubeupload “seems like what folks should be using”?

I agree. If the issue was still up for discussion, the topic would not be closed. The fact that that thread is now closed makes @paddle2see's word final until further notice.

Last edited by RobotChickens (Dec. 2, 2023 22:39:08)

I will be refraining from active and frequent participation in forum discourse
until the Gen-Alpha Linguistic Epidemic* subsides into eradication,
if or when such an event will occur in the near future.
(Let me know when it's safe to come out. I'll be lurking in the ATs.)

✊ Support the suggestion HERE by adding this button to your signature ✊

[url=scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/557083/][img]u.cubeupload.com/RBC/FmjBtn.gif[/img][/url]

[SIGNATURE UNDER CONSTRUCTION]

*brainrot

k7e

Out of curiosity, does the new filter let you edit the topic? It let me quote the entire thing and post it (which I removed), but I am wondering because the image in 1.11 is hosted on assets with the get image part, and because 7.1 mentions [blue-purple app].

Last edited by k7e (Dec. 3, 2023 02:47:10)

@mythoslore was so much more obvious than @spookily

Za-Chary

bugsyk2009 wrote:
Asset links were popularized by the extension when a tweak was added to it that allows you to upload an image file to it and get the link. If I remember correctly, assets.scratch.mit.edu stores the files for projects, including costumes. I'm guessing this worked by creating an unshared project on some account with your image as a costume, then retrieving the assets link for that costume.

It would be used as a convenient alternative to Cubeupload and a way to post clickable links to images in comments (as reaction images, etc.), and it was more likely to be unblocked on any school computer where Scratch is as well, where as Cubeupload tends to be blocked.

Thanks for the lesson. Do we think that uncensoring assets.scratch.mit.edu should be added to this list? I'm hesitant to do so if its history is rooted in browser extensions, but maybe I'm just too tired to think rationally at the moment.

Zydrolic wrote:
I thought I saw an st member post around yesterday
but ig I daydreamed since I can't find it anymore i should probably start writing sources down instead since im starting to forget a lot-

I asked @Paddle2See, who stated that it was for security reasons — not for being underused.

k7e wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
Now, the question is whether or not this was actually popular. It's easy to say something is “popular” when you are thrust into a community that uses it a lot. Kind of like the forums — many forum users think the forums are “popular.” But in reality, less than 1% of Scratchers use the forums.
Nearly every image I see posted on the forums is hosted with assets, as a popular browser extension most forum users use add a button where you can upload images using assets.

Also, note that I was not trying to imply that a large percentage of users use assets, but it is certainly popular among forum users, and there are several rejected suggestions on this list regarding the forums.

Yeah kinda an L argument on my part. I'm still not too happy that this all came into play due to browser extensions, though.

k7e wrote:
It is the link to costume or backdrop images that are stored on the Scratch servers. The aforementioned browser extension added a button on the forums where you upload a file, and then it creates a new Scratch project, uploads the image into it, gets the link to the image on the servers, and then deletes the project. Users preferred using it instead of, for instance, Cubeupload, because assets would never go down unless Scratch went down, and a school filter would never block it unless the school filter blocked Scratch.

Thanks for the lesson.

This is my forum signature! On a forum post, it is okay for Scratchers to advertise in their forum signature. The signature is the stuff that shows up below the horizontal line on the post. It will show up on every post I make.

I was a Scratch Team member from May 10th 2019 to October 29th 2021. I reached 20,000 forum posts on June 24th 2024.

my notebook | scratch team essay | accessibility essay

k7e

k7e wrote:
Out of curiosity, does the new filter let you edit the topic? It let me quote the entire thing and post it (which I removed), but I am wondering because the image in 1.11 is hosted on assets with the get image part, and because 7.1 mentions [blue-purple app].

Bumping this.

@mythoslore was so much more obvious than @spookily

Sliverus

Za-Chary wrote:
Thanks for the lesson. Do we think that uncensoring assets.scratch.mit.edu should be added to this list? I'm hesitant to do so if its history is rooted in browser extensions, but maybe I'm just too tired to think rationally at the moment.

I think this is a reasonable idea to add to the list. I think its roots in browser extensions are what Paddle meant when he said assets was never intended to be used that way, anyway. So, you could explain in your entry that it was an unintentional feature which wasn't supposed to exist in the first place, that was being repeatedly abused by spammers.

My Scratch Essays | Notebook | Generic Platformer Essay | Guide to Overcome Forum Addiction | Internets

Be moist

Zydrolic

Za-Chary wrote:
(#7894)
I asked @Paddle2See, who stated that it was for security reasons — not for being underused.

Ah my apologies then.

Please stop posting on rulebreaking topics no matter what | forum icons | if you responded to a post by this account, slide a comment to @coughfe please, as i might take 2 months or longer to respond with this one (i moved)

Toru said:

“全てが終わってその後に残るものは…夢と……想い出だけだそれだけだ”

leahcimto

deleted

Last edited by leahcimto (Dec. 3, 2023 17:35:54)

TheEpikGamer211

Hello, about rejected suggestion no. 8.2, I have found a Forum moderator rank.

Epik gamer 211. Proud inventor of GTTSTES.
I'm a he.
I'm workng on
SC (then SBOX)
GTTSTES 1.3

when (::ff0000) horribly misclicked and pressed @greenFlag instead.:: hat :: events 
Summon Evil Kumquats using (((((((((((((:D):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion :: motion)

Zydrolic

TheEpikGamer211 wrote:
(#7899)
Hello, about rejected suggestion no. 8.2, I have found a Forum moderator rank.

They are 18+, former ST member - It's a real rank, however there's barely any of them in existance.

Please stop posting on rulebreaking topics no matter what | forum icons | if you responded to a post by this account, slide a comment to @coughfe please, as i might take 2 months or longer to respond with this one (i moved)

Toru said:

“全てが終わってその後に残るものは…夢と……想い出だけだそれだけだ”

k7e

Zydrolic wrote:
TheEpikGamer211 wrote:
(#7899)
Hello, about rejected suggestion no. 8.2, I have found a Forum moderator rank.
They are 18+, former ST member - It's a real rank, however there's barely any of them in existance.

It's “forum moderator”, not “former moderator” – those are the users that are still Community Moderators from before the program ended.

Last edited by k7e (Dec. 3, 2023 19:49:26)

@mythoslore was so much more obvious than @spookily

HurricaneMitch1998M

Zydrolic wrote:
TheEpikGamer211 wrote:
(#7899)
Hello, about rejected suggestion no. 8.2, I have found a Forum moderator rank.
They are 18+, former ST member - It's a real rank, however there's barely any of them in existance.

Do you mean they have been on scratch when forum moderator was a real rank?

My studio

when green flag clicked
forever
stay up until 1am questioning my existence
end

Sliverus

Let's try to keep this discussion on-topic. Any questions about the current subject can be discussed either in Questions about Scratch or another user's profile.

Last edited by Sliverus (Dec. 4, 2023 01:08:00)

My Scratch Essays | Notebook | Generic Platformer Essay | Guide to Overcome Forum Addiction | Internets

Be moist

epicdude512

I think we should add “Ban certain project type” to the TOLORS, as i have seen multiple people suggest removing types of projects they do not like, but the projects are not breaking the rules.

I am small developer with big ambitions who likes to frequent the forums, Currently i’m working on a game called the battle sticks! the battle sticks is a single player action game with inspired by battle cats! if thats you cup of tea then press this Link and play for yourself, if you don’t want to play, thats ok! i wont force you. Have a great day!

Sliverus

epicdude512 wrote:
I think we should add “Ban certain project type” to the TOLORS, as i have seen multiple people suggest removing types of projects they do not like, but the projects are not breaking the rules.

Any examples?

My Scratch Essays | Notebook | Generic Platformer Essay | Guide to Overcome Forum Addiction | Internets

Be moist

Zydrolic

Sliverus wrote:
(#7905)
Any examples?

Most of the warrior cats ones are probably a good example, there were a lot of those (or those are questions I'm remembering from QaS as I legit cannot find any of them anymore).

Please stop posting on rulebreaking topics no matter what | forum icons | if you responded to a post by this account, slide a comment to @coughfe please, as i might take 2 months or longer to respond with this one (i moved)

Toru said:

“全てが終わってその後に残るものは…夢と……想い出だけだそれだけだ”

k7e

Zydrolic wrote:
Sliverus wrote:
(#7905)
Any examples?
Most of the warrior cats ones are probably a good example, there were a lot of those (or those are questions I'm remembering from QaS as I legit cannot find any of them anymore).

Isn't that already rejected under “ban a certain franchise”?

@mythoslore was so much more obvious than @spookily

teamsonic2011

k7e wrote:
Zydrolic wrote:
Sliverus wrote:
(#7905)
Any examples?
Most of the warrior cats ones are probably a good example, there were a lot of those (or those are questions I'm remembering from QaS as I legit cannot find any of them anymore).
Isn't that already rejected under “ban a certain franchise”?

I think so.

Just a 13 year old who likes dragons

Give me an internet • “No.” - Za-Chary • check out my new website

Sliverus

k7e wrote:
Isn't that already rejected under “ban a certain franchise”?

I think that particular example, yes. But some other types of project ban suggestions, such as banning generic platformers, wouldn't qualify as being under a particular franchise.

My Scratch Essays | Notebook | Generic Platformer Essay | Guide to Overcome Forum Addiction | Internets

Be moist

Discuss Scratch