AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

Ranking the Star Wars TV Shows

1. Visions (10/10)
2. Andor (9.5/10)
3. Star Wars Rebels (9.5/10)
4. The Mandalorian (8.5/10)
5. The Book of Boba Fett (7/10)
6. Ahsoka (6/10)
7. Obi-Wan Kenobi (4/10)

No way you put BOBF about Ahsoka
Haven’t seen Visions so idk.

Ahsoka is a mediocre, overrated, and unnecessary TV show that does nothing but erase everything meaningful about the Rebels ending.

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

Dave Filoni is now apparently Lucasfilms chief creator officer.

NOOOOOOO

YESSSSSSS

He doesn't… tell stories. He just goes “Look, it's that thing! Clap!”.

TCW, Rebels, Ahsoka, First 2 seasons of Mando.

I have seen 4 seasons of that and I can name… 2 good arcs. Pong Krell and the Godzilla one for its pure insanity.
Remind me again what pre existing characters they introduced? Oh, right. The one's Filoni created because he couldn't let them go.
See above
*1st season. Half of the second season was literally exactly what I said.

Your personal taste, and your judging the entire show on 4 seasons.
Because TCW was cancelled before he could finish those characters stories.
Ahsoka continues the story from Rebels, thats like complaining about Empire continuing from A New Hope.
So it made you hate the entire season?

Anyway I’m done arguing over this, if you think all of it is bad then that’s your problem. I’m not the one missing out lol.

I am judging it based on 2/3 of the show.
It's not that hard. Rex did Order 66 and Ahsoka died.
WHY DID IT NEED TO BE LIVE ACTION
The season itself isn't terrible, it's what it represents that is. And also robo-Luke. That's awful.

Thats like someone watching the sequels, Phantom Menace, and Attack of the Clones and judging all the films.
The (at the time) ending does not suggest that at all.
Yea I have no idea why live action. I actually kinda agree since I would prefer the original actors.
Robo Luke is… yea… but its not the worse (Flash, Rouge One *cough cough*)

No, because that's not watching them in order. It's not like I watched the first 3 and a half seasons then skipped to the last one.
Yeah… because nobody in universe knew that would happen.
That's like saying “Yeah, he murdered someone but at least he wasn't a serial killer.”

Fair.
I mean with (spoiler but you prob don’t care) Ahsoka leaving the Jedi order, she wouldn’t be taken by Order 66. And Rex was AWARE of the chips.
Still, Rouge One was worse about it and people do not care and never bring it up. Yet continue to trash on Filoni for it when he may have had nothing to do with it.

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

Dave Filoni is now apparently Lucasfilms chief creator officer.

NOOOOOOO

YESSSSSSS

He doesn't… tell stories. He just goes “Look, it's that thing! Clap!”.

TCW, Rebels, Ahsoka, First 2 seasons of Mando.

I have seen 4 seasons of that and I can name… 2 good arcs. Pong Krell and the Godzilla one for its pure insanity.
Remind me again what pre existing characters they introduced? Oh, right. The one's Filoni created because he couldn't let them go.
See above
*1st season. Half of the second season was literally exactly what I said.

Your personal taste, and your judging the entire show on 4 seasons.
Because TCW was cancelled before he could finish those characters stories.
Ahsoka continues the story from Rebels, thats like complaining about Empire continuing from A New Hope.
So it made you hate the entire season?

Anyway I’m done arguing over this, if you think all of it is bad then that’s your problem. I’m not the one missing out lol.

I am judging it based on 2/3 of the show.
It's not that hard. Rex did Order 66 and Ahsoka died.
WHY DID IT NEED TO BE LIVE ACTION
The season itself isn't terrible, it's what it represents that is. And also robo-Luke. That's awful.

Thats like someone watching the sequels, Phantom Menace, and Attack of the Clones and judging all the films.
The (at the time) ending does not suggest that at all.
Yea I have no idea why live action. I actually kinda agree since I would prefer the original actors.
Robo Luke is… yea… but its not the worse (Flash, Rouge One *cough cough*)

No, because that's not watching them in order. It's not like I watched the first 3 and a half seasons then skipped to the last one.
Yeah… because nobody in universe knew that would happen.
That's like saying “Yeah, he murdered someone but at least he wasn't a serial killer.”

Fair.
I mean with (spoiler but you prob don’t care) Ahsoka leaving the Jedi order, she wouldn’t be taken by Order 66. And Rex was AWARE of the chips.
Still, Rouge One was worse about it and people do not care and never bring it up. Yet continue to trash on Filoni for it when he may have had nothing to do with it.

Great. Still doesn't mean they need to take over another show.
… did you just try to say Filoni was not involved with the climax of his show? And people don't bring up Rogue One because that was in 2016. Robo-Luke last showed up in 2022.

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

Dave Filoni is now apparently Lucasfilms chief creator officer.

NOOOOOOO

YESSSSSSS

He doesn't… tell stories. He just goes “Look, it's that thing! Clap!”.

TCW, Rebels, Ahsoka, First 2 seasons of Mando.

I have seen 4 seasons of that and I can name… 2 good arcs. Pong Krell and the Godzilla one for its pure insanity.
Remind me again what pre existing characters they introduced? Oh, right. The one's Filoni created because he couldn't let them go.
See above
*1st season. Half of the second season was literally exactly what I said.

Your personal taste, and your judging the entire show on 4 seasons.
Because TCW was cancelled before he could finish those characters stories.
Ahsoka continues the story from Rebels, thats like complaining about Empire continuing from A New Hope.
So it made you hate the entire season?

Anyway I’m done arguing over this, if you think all of it is bad then that’s your problem. I’m not the one missing out lol.

I am judging it based on 2/3 of the show.
It's not that hard. Rex did Order 66 and Ahsoka died.
WHY DID IT NEED TO BE LIVE ACTION
The season itself isn't terrible, it's what it represents that is. And also robo-Luke. That's awful.

Thats like someone watching the sequels, Phantom Menace, and Attack of the Clones and judging all the films.
The (at the time) ending does not suggest that at all.
Yea I have no idea why live action. I actually kinda agree since I would prefer the original actors.
Robo Luke is… yea… but its not the worse (Flash, Rouge One *cough cough*)

No, because that's not watching them in order. It's not like I watched the first 3 and a half seasons then skipped to the last one.
Yeah… because nobody in universe knew that would happen.
That's like saying “Yeah, he murdered someone but at least he wasn't a serial killer.”

Fair.
I mean with (spoiler but you prob don’t care) Ahsoka leaving the Jedi order, she wouldn’t be taken by Order 66. And Rex was AWARE of the chips.
Still, Rouge One was worse about it and people do not care and never bring it up. Yet continue to trash on Filoni for it when he may have had nothing to do with it.

Great. Still doesn't mean they need to take over another show.
… did you just try to say Filoni was not involved with the climax of his show? And people don't bring up Rogue One because that was in 2016. Robo-Luke last showed up in 2022.

They didn’t though? You didn’t even watch it?
Didn’t say that, I said he could be not involved with that one part of the finale. After all he’s only a cocreator, Jon Favreau exists.
Mark Hammil is alive and allowed it, Rouge One spit on their graves.

HexagonWorld wrote:

I have watched 4 seasons of Clone Wars, I'm not watching Rebels.

HexagonWorld wrote:

Rex did Order 66 and Ahsoka died.

boom2ratz wrote:

Best Star Wars in my opinion:

1. Rogue One
2. The Mandalorian Season 1
3. Empire Strikes Back

boom2ratz wrote:

Best Star Wars in my opinion:

1. Rogue One
2. The Mandalorian Season 1
3. Empire Strikes Back

boom2ratz wrote:

Best Star Wars in my opinion:

1. Rogue One
2. The Mandalorian Season 1
3. Empire Strikes Back

Platypus_WKeyboard wrote:

boom2ratz wrote:

Best Star Wars in my opinion:

1. Rogue One
2. The Mandalorian Season 1
3. Empire Strikes Back

tbh the best Star Wars film is Rise of Skywalker

Platypus_WKeyboard wrote:

boom2ratz wrote:

Best Star Wars in my opinion:

1. Rogue One
2. The Mandalorian Season 1
3. Empire Strikes Back

tbh the best Star Wars film is Rise of Skywalker

Platypus_WKeyboard wrote:

boom2ratz wrote:

Best Star Wars in my opinion:

1. Rogue One
2. The Mandalorian Season 1
3. Empire Strikes Back

tbh the best Star Wars film is Rise of Skywalker

AbeHe wrote:

Watched the first 3 episodes of season 3 for Bad Batch, enjoyed em.

Codey9 wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

Watched the first 3 episodes of season 3 for Bad Batch, enjoyed em.

Nice, I watched them yesterday.

LuigiFan5204 wrote:

Codey9 wrote:

AbeHe wrote:

Watched the first 3 episodes of season 3 for Bad Batch, enjoyed em.

Nice, I watched them yesterday.

I don't actually want this to happen but if they do end up making Omega force sensitive not so long after making Sabine force sensitive it would honestly be kind of funny

HexagonWorld wrote:

The Acolyte sounds… good? Wait, what? Live-action Star Wars TV isn't supposed to be good, I thought Andor was just a fluke.

Codey9 wrote:

HexagonWorld wrote:

The Acolyte sounds… good? Wait, what? Live-action Star Wars TV isn't supposed to be good, I thought Andor was just a fluke.

I have my expectations very low, but I hope it's good.