Discuss Scratch

SebDev_12
Scratcher
100+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

I'm making a WW2 game, which is like a game called Hearts of Iron IV. When you click on a country, the diplomacy menu opens. Like Hearts of Iron, I want to display a portrait of the leader, and their name. But then I have Germany, and it's leader at the time. How should I do this, do I need to put a black box over his face or can I display his whole face?
reinecloud
Scratcher
1 post

How strict should I be on this?

I think you should play it safe and censor the face. Otherwise, it might cross the community guidelines.
SebDev_12
Scratcher
100+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

reinecloud wrote:

I think you should play it safe and censor the face. Otherwise, it might cross the community guidelines.
ok, I'll add a black rectangle over his face
Spentine
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

Some may be able to argue that it's educational since you're using real portraits and names of various leaders. Scratch allows for educational content, even if the content itself may break the CG.

Posting a wound would break the rules, but if it's mostly educational and shares important facts and names of the various parts of the wound along with its medical name, it could be considered to be allowed since it's educational.

It's difficult to decide if it's truly allowed, so someone such as that former Scratch team member who is active on the forums and I forgot the name of could probably answer the question with a bit of certainty.
INSERT-USER_NAME
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

Spentine wrote:

It's difficult to decide if it's truly allowed, so someone such as that former Scratch team member who is active on the forums and I forgot the name of could probably answer the question with a bit of certainty.
@Za-Chary?
Spentine
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

INSERT-USER_NAME wrote:

Spentine wrote:

It's difficult to decide if it's truly allowed, so someone such as that former Scratch team member who is active on the forums and I forgot the name of could probably answer the question with a bit of certainty.
@Za-Chary?
yes
medians
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

Spentine wrote:

INSERT-USER_NAME wrote:

Spentine wrote:

It's difficult to decide if it's truly allowed, so someone such as that former Scratch team member who is active on the forums and I forgot the name of could probably answer the question with a bit of certainty.
@Za-Chary?
yes
za-chary

Spentine wrote:

Some may be able to argue that it's educational since you're using real portraits and names of various leaders. Scratch allows for educational content, even if the content itself may break the CG.
I mean, I think we should wait and see because I did hear that this was allowed from Paddle2See, but I could be wrong.
-RabbitWorld-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

There's nothing inappropriate about the German leader of that time's face. lol I think it should be fine.
medians
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

There's nothing inappropriate about the German leader of that time's face. lol I think it should be fine.
I think they meant because of who he was.
Spentine
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

There's nothing inappropriate about the German leader of that time's face. lol I think it should be fine.
His name is Adolf Hitler. He was the leader of the Nazis. He decided to kill millions of Jewish people just because they're Jewish (people can't control their race so they're basically innocent)
INSERT-USER_NAME
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

Spentine wrote:

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

There's nothing inappropriate about the German leader of that time's face. lol I think it should be fine.
Austrian painter lore
st action incoming
-RabbitWorld-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

Spentine wrote:

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

There's nothing inappropriate about the German leader of that time's face. lol I think it should be fine.
His name is Adolf Hitler. He was the leader of the Nazis. He decided to kill millions of Jewish people just because they're Jewish (people can't control their race so they're basically innocent)
I know who they are talking about and what Hitler has done already. But it should be fine to post his picture of his face. They just need to not be racist themselves. Note: I don't support Hitler

Last edited by -RabbitWorld- (May 13, 2023 00:44:01)

Spentine
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

INSERT-USER_NAME wrote:

Spentine wrote:

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

There's nothing inappropriate about the German leader of that time's face. lol I think it should be fine.
Austrian painter lore
st action incoming
no i'm telling them for the purposes of education
Za-Chary
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

I know who they are talking about and what Hitler has done already. But it should be fine to post his picture of his face. They just need to not be racist themselves. Note: I don't support Hitler
You can only post pictures of Hitler if there is a clear educational/historical context from doing so. But, for example, you can't set your profile picture to Hitler's face, even if you don't say anywhere that you support him.
INSERT-USER_NAME
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

Spentine wrote:

INSERT-USER_NAME wrote:

Spentine wrote:

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

There's nothing inappropriate about the German leader of that time's face. lol I think it should be fine.
Austrian painter lore
st action incoming
no i'm telling them for the purposes of education
I'd advise making that clear in your post, I may be slightly paranoid but still.
Spentine
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

Za-Chary wrote:

You can only post pictures of Hitler if there is a clear educational/historical context from doing so.
Alright, I guess this settles it. The game has a clear historical context (WW2 game), so it is alright to include Hitler's face.
DifferentDance8
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

looks fine to me, as it's in a clear historical context (a WW2 game)
PaperMarioFan2022
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

That also concludes pfp of the flag, right?

Za-Chary wrote:

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

I know who they are talking about and what Hitler has done already. But it should be fine to post his picture of his face. They just need to not be racist themselves. Note: I don't support Hitler
You can only post pictures of Hitler if there is a clear educational/historical context from doing so. But, for example, you can't set your profile picture to Hitler's face, even if you don't say anywhere that you support him.
Does that also conclude his flag? Someone used to put his party flag as their pfp.

Also, this doesn’t mean I support Hitler for his actions.

Last edited by PaperMarioFan2022 (May 13, 2023 15:13:47)

-gr
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

(#18)
That also concludes pfp of the flag, right?

Za-Chary wrote:

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

I know who they are talking about and what Hitler has done already. But it should be fine to post his picture of his face. They just need to not be racist themselves. Note: I don't support Hitler
You can only post pictures of Hitler if there is a clear educational/historical context from doing so. But, for example, you can't set your profile picture to Hitler's face, even if you don't say anywhere that you support him.
Does that also conclude his flag? Someone used to put his party flag as their pfp.
I doubt that's allowed, and you should report that user. It's a symbol of hate.
PaperMarioFan2022
Scratcher
1000+ posts

How strict should I be on this?

-gr wrote:

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

(#18)
That also concludes pfp of the flag, right?

Za-Chary wrote:

-RabbitWorld- wrote:

I know who they are talking about and what Hitler has done already. But it should be fine to post his picture of his face. They just need to not be racist themselves. Note: I don't support Hitler
You can only post pictures of Hitler if there is a clear educational/historical context from doing so. But, for example, you can't set your profile picture to Hitler's face, even if you don't say anywhere that you support him.
Does that also conclude his flag? Someone used to put his party flag as their pfp.
I doubt that's allowed, and you should report that user. It's a symbol of hate.

They were reported for using it after I saw their profile, I might’ve reported it but I got banned after saying something bad that meant to take back.

Powered by DjangoBB