Don't remove automatic remix credit when the original is unshared

samq64

Support! The remix tree shows unshared projects (although I don't think it displays the project's title) so why doesn't the remixing credit?

Maximouse

Bump.

ScolderCreations

Maximouse wrote:
Bump.

In my opinion, I think this might cause problems, but I do think it is a feature that makes sense to implement. I think most people would rather see this implemented first, and then any problems could be worked out. Semi-support.

Pds314

gosoccerboy5 wrote:
Actually I believe they should keep the link. I'm gonna get in trouble for saying this probably but sometimes I like to view unshared projects through TurboWarp

See this is why it should remove the link. That's cool but it's pretty much the ur example of project saves being insecure.

lapisi

Pds314 wrote:
gosoccerboy5 wrote:
Actually I believe they should keep the link. I'm gonna get in trouble for saying this probably but sometimes I like to view unshared projects through TurboWarp

See this is why it should remove the link. That's cool but it's pretty much the ur example of project saves being insecure.

disable the link and keep the credit

MOCKUP OF THIS:

Maximouse

Bump.

VedanshS933

Support! We need to give credits. The orignal mockup is better

SuperMarioHome

Maximouse wrote:
Bump.

Why did you bump? Post #85 was 3 months ago.

Maximouse

SuperMarioHome wrote:
Maximouse wrote:
Bump.
Why did you bump? Post #85 was 3 months ago.

The suggestion is still relevant.

Jackson49_test

Bump

colinmacc

This seems to be a reasonable suggestion

historical_supa

This would be great since many remixes have deleted original projects, so people think “hey you're the original creator”. This would also solve issues with mass-reporting, since someone could mass-report an original project and remix it without any changes.

Last edited by historical_supa (April 15, 2022 11:20:38)

k0d3rrr

A “very tired of bumps” bump…

Maximouse

Bump.

eikh2

Going up

rockerstage02

even though this post is from a while ago i still think it holds up as a good idea. i was thinking maybe it wouldnt be a link, rather a grey text box saying "The original project has been unshared. " or somthing like that.

Last edited by rockerstage02 (Dec. 22, 2022 20:12:26)

lapisi

rockerstage02 wrote:
(#96)
even though this post is from a while ago i still think it holds up as a good idea. i was thinking maybe it wouldnt be a link, rather a grey text box saying "The original project has been unshared. " or somthing like that.

well unshared projects are no longer visible on third party sites so I think it can just be included as is

Maximouse

Bump.

breakfast_for_dinner

i remember a remix of an unshared project was featured once. there was a lot of backlash, and the user felt really guilty about it and unshared the remix. this would prevent a similar ordeal from happening again. i like this idea

Elijah999999

gosoccerboy5 wrote:
Actually I believe they should keep the link. I'm gonna get in trouble for saying this probably but sometimes I like to view unshared projects through TurboWarp

I know this is an old post, but thank GOODNESS people can't do that any more…

Discuss Scratch