apng files are not supported, they are imported as standard png files

and if you mess around with the zip file (sb3 files are zip files) generated by clicking “Save to your computer” and try to overwrite the png file with your apng file, this happens

here is the file (from scratch cdn): https://assets.scratch.mit.edu/internalapi/asset/ce02a645e11d21b7511d26171bbf526a.png/get/
you'll notice that if you open it with the windows photo app (or most other image viewing/editing apps), it only shows the first frame, but if you open it with a chromium-based browser (e.g. chrome/edge), it shows the apng file correctly

Support, but isn't the same as animated SVGs? I'm not talking about SVGs here, however. Support, if it imports it like a regular ol' GIF.

lolecksdeehaha wrote:

Support, but isn't the same as animated SVGs? I'm not talking about SVGs here, however. Support, if it imports it like a regular ol' GIF.

Yeah, that's what I mean, if it could import it like a GIF.

bump

bump (why does nobody care about this general issue?)

APNG files are better than GIFs in almost every way. The only problem is that Edge 15-18 don't support, but we could probably drop support for those versions.

dhuls wrote:

APNG files are better than GIFs in almost every way. The only problem is that Edge 15-18 don't support, but we could probably drop support for those versions.

Microsoft is migrating people from Microsoft Edge Legacy and it is extremely hard to get that version without ending up with malware, so it's probably fine.

dhuls wrote:

APNG files are better than GIFs in almost every way. The only problem is that Edge 15-18 don't support, but we could probably drop support for those versions.

Or they could just drop support for Edge in general. :P

SuperSonicmario wrote:

dhuls wrote:

APNG files are better than GIFs in almost every way. The only problem is that Edge 15-18 don't support, but we could probably drop support for those versions.

Or they could just drop support for Edge in general. :P

nonononononononononononononononononononononononnONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONO





the new edge is based off of chromium it's much better and it stands a chance agaisnt hcdrome

SuperSonicmario wrote:

(#8)

dhuls wrote:

APNG files are better than GIFs in almost every way. The only problem is that Edge 15-18 don't support, but we could probably drop support for those versions.

Or they could just drop support for Edge in general. :P

It's more used than Firefox on desktop and slightly less used than Firefox when including mobile.
Plus, Edge is based off of Chromium, which is what Chrome is also based off of. It's no additional effort to support Edge Chromium than it is to support Chrome (especially since most ST members use macOS and Chrome)

dhuls wrote:

APNG files are better than GIFs in almost every way

Yes.

• Free format
  
• More than 256 colors
  
• Better compression
  
• PNG is cool
  

bump

bump