Merge the two "my stuff" buttons.

BearSlothCoding

On phones, there is no button so the dropdown is actually important. Even if there was, this looks rather empty.

While looking at that image, I can't help but feel that it needs something.

Now, you're probably thinking that we should remove the icon and just leave it in the dropdown. But this also looks weird and like it needs something.

However, it looks better in 3.0 style. So maybe once they make all of the pages 3.0, then the icon could be removed.

Last edited by BearSlothCoding (Dec. 25, 2021 13:11:25)

ScratchMan6961

I always use the dropdown mystuff sooooo I dont like this idea

jaguar1501

ScratchMan6961 wrote:
I always use the dropdown mystuff sooooo I dont like this idea

This isn't specifically asking to remove the dropdown My Stuff, just to remove one of the two.

ScratchMan6961

jaguar1501 wrote:
This isn't specifically asking to remove the dropdown My Stuff, just to remove one of the two.

Yeah but most the people here support this so if you remove the icon they're gonna be sad and you have people like me who like the dropdown

jaguar1501

ScratchMan6961 wrote:
jaguar1501 wrote:
This isn't specifically asking to remove the dropdown My Stuff, just to remove one of the two.

Yeah but most the people here support this so if you remove the icon they're gonna be sad and you have people like me who like the dropdown

I prefer the dropdown too. I personally don't think it's necessary to remove either of the buttons, to be honest.

worldPOKEMONchampion

yzyzyz wrote:

so recently I talked with @fancyfoxy about the fact that for no reason, there are TWO SEPARATE “my stuff” buttons on the main menu.
I think this double button is unnecessary, and you only need to have just one.
please suggest which one of them should be removed
supporters: 6
drop down:3 sidebar:3 whichever:0
this time, I will not create a giant studio. This is a smaller problem than bringing back the discuss tab.
keep scratching! @yzyzyz

I like having both in case one isn't working or your screen is small.

earthly_home

BearSlothCoding wrote:
On phones, there is no button so the dropdown is actually important. Even if there was, this looks rather empty.

While looking at that image, I can't help but feel that it needs something.

-snip-

True. But I hardly ever use that. It could be replaced by something? The other option looks kind of empty too, so the ST would probably have to replace it instead.

BearSlothCoding

earthly_home wrote:
BearSlothCoding wrote:
On phones, there is no button so the dropdown is actually important. Even if there was, this looks rather empty.

While looking at that image, I can't help but feel that it needs something.

-snip-
True. But I hardly ever use that. It could be replaced by something? The other option looks kind of empty too, so the ST would probably have to replace it instead.

BearSlothCoding wrote:
However, it looks better in 3.0 style. So maybe once they make all of the pages 3.0, then the icon could be removed.

earthly_home

BearSlothCoding wrote:
earthly_home wrote:
BearSlothCoding wrote:
On phones, there is no button so the dropdown is actually important. Even if there was, this looks rather empty.

While looking at that image, I can't help but feel that it needs something.

-snip-
True. But I hardly ever use that. It could be replaced by something? The other option looks kind of empty too, so the ST would probably have to replace it instead.
BearSlothCoding wrote:
However, it looks better in 3.0 style. So maybe once they make all of the pages 3.0, then the icon could be removed.

Still looks a bit empty imo

arvepro3579

Downdrop is the things that you owe, so I think in that case you should remove the one that isn't on the Downdrop.

mtech22

bump

TERASMAJESTICACCOUNT

switch backdrop to [no v] and wait

no

mybearworld

Support! The my stuff button in the header is useless, and should be where the other account-related option is, the dropdown.
Mockup:

mumu245

Auroura_Wolf wrote:
Aha, you made it! So, yeah, like I said on the other topic, I would support this, and personally I would remove the one on the bar, not in the drop down menu
EDIT: my reasoning is just that it slightly shortens the bar, it's more clear what it does (it actually says it, instead of being a symbol) and I'm personally accustomed to using the drop down one

Yes

HenryOmarCCCmango_2

duckboycool wrote:
What's the point of removing the one in the dropdown?

No support, I think that the button should stay there, and it's not causing any problems in the dropdown.

They never said that they want to remove the drop-down one. They just want to know which one should be removed, the one on the bar or the profile drop-down one…

mrgame2012

I would remove the drop-down “My stuff” button. It's dead weight right now, unless the ST adds a separate button for studios

DinoMaster20

I'll support. I would remove the dropdown personally, because I use the button next to messages way more often.

Virus6120

No support. It's not breaking anything, it's not interfering with anything, and sometimes a little bit of redundancy is nice.

I'd imagine removing any of these would spark some controversy since by just reading the posts on this forum some use the button on the navbar, some use the button in the dropdown menu.

Personally I tend to use either, I don't really lean toward any side.

dhuls

DinoMaster20 wrote:
(#77)
I'll support. I would remove the dropdown personally, because I use the button next to messages way more often.

What about these:

VeryFamus

No support. They aren’t necessary to have both, but removing one would cause complaints and is unnecessary to remove.

Discuss Scratch