Discuss Scratch

sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

I made a project called Destroy the Teddy, I am worried that it might be against the rules because

Paddle2See wrote:

Go ahead and report those if they have any kind of extreme violence (blood, dismemberment, etc.) or they involve a real person as the target. There may be other reasons to consider reporting, even if neither of those elements are present, such as if they target a specific section of the community.
It contains quite a lots of violence against a teddy bear, including a gun and dismemberment (and to win, you must rip the teddy bear into pieces, however, I'm not sure if it is allowed or not because the target is a teddy bear instead of people or animals




Please do not report the project because I already censored the game, I want to keep the original date

Last edited by sharkode (Oct. 25, 2021 23:06:14)

mrcreatorluigi
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

There’s actually a few violent things in there; possibly the gun, and maybe the teddy being dismembered. You can keep the teddy, but try and remove the fluff coming out of it. But remove the gun entirely; I think that’s a little too violent.
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

mrcreatorluigi wrote:

There’s actually a few violent things in there; possibly the gun, and maybe the teddy being dismembered. You can keep the teddy, but try and remove the fluff coming out of it. But remove the gun entirely; I think that’s a little too violent.
I think guns are allowed, because
1. It is not realistic
2. You're shooting a Teddy bear

The stuff coming out of it is cotton, everybody has seen those so I don't think there's anything wrong with it

Last edited by sharkode (Oct. 25, 2021 20:42:18)

g4tor2010
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

Still, the stuff coming out of the teddy bear might promote violence. Plus, a sort of unofficial rule is that if you search a key word, and nothing comes up, and you know that a project's bound to have that thing you looked up included in the project, then it's probably not a good idea to include it. Ex. if you look up “guns” in the search, and nothing comes up, then it's not ok to post something about it. Guns are marked as NFE (not for everyone), I think.
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

g4tor2010 wrote:

Still, the stuff coming out of the teddy bear might promote violence. Plus, a sort of unofficial rule is that if you search a key word, and nothing comes up, and you know that a project's bound to have that thing you looked up included in the project, then it's probably not a good idea to include it. Ex. if you look up “guns” in the search, and nothing comes up, then it's not ok to post something about it. Guns are marked as NFE (not for everyone), I think.
Cotton promoting violence? I don't understand
g4tor2010
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

I mean, not like the cotton itself, but the fact that something's coming out from the insides of the teddy bear.

Last edited by g4tor2010 (Oct. 25, 2021 21:17:37)

sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

g4tor2010 wrote:

I mean, not like the cotton itself, but the fact that something's coming out from the insides of the teddy bear.
Rules on Scratch is definitely weird, other people's can make shooting games (with real guns, not lasers or nerf guns) without getting into troubles, and I might get into trouble because my project contains a bit of cotton
han614698
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

sharkode wrote:

mrcreatorluigi wrote:

There’s actually a few violent things in there; possibly the gun, and maybe the teddy being dismembered. You can keep the teddy, but try and remove the fluff coming out of it. But remove the gun entirely; I think that’s a little too violent.
I think guns are allowed, because
1. It is not realistic
2. You're shooting a Teddy bear

The stuff coming out of it is cotton, everybody has seen those so I don't think there's anything wrong with it
FYI -
Your gun is realistic, and shooting anything (including targets???) is not allowed.
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

han614698 wrote:

sharkode wrote:

mrcreatorluigi wrote:

There’s actually a few violent things in there; possibly the gun, and maybe the teddy being dismembered. You can keep the teddy, but try and remove the fluff coming out of it. But remove the gun entirely; I think that’s a little too violent.
I think guns are allowed, because
1. It is not realistic
2. You're shooting a Teddy bear

The stuff coming out of it is cotton, everybody has seen those so I don't think there's anything wrong with it
FYI -
Your gun is realistic, and shooting anything (including targets???) is not allowed.
The gun is not realistic, the only realistic thing about the gun is its icon, it works like other weapons except it deals more damage

Last edited by sharkode (Oct. 25, 2021 22:00:01)

warriorcatz2009
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

If the blood and the teddy bear looks realistic and there’s scary images then it would break the CG
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

warriorcatz2009 wrote:

If the blood and the teddy bear looks realistic and there’s scary images then it would break the CG
1. No blood, just cotton
2. Not true. Destroying a realistic teddy bear is not against the rules
3. Does a pile of cotton and cloth count as too scary?
OhOkSir12345
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

possibly, because its only an object, it might be marked NFE
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

OhOkSir12345 wrote:

possibly, because its only an object, it might be marked NFE
I doubt it
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

Ok someone made a recolour of my project, I'm just going to report it and see what happens
TurtleLegos
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

sharkode wrote:

Ok someone made a recolour of my project, I'm just going to report it and see what happens
You are not supposed to report recolors!
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

TurtleLegos wrote:

sharkode wrote:

Ok someone made a recolour of my project, I'm just going to report it and see what happens
You are not supposed to report recolors!
I am reporting it not because it is a recolour, I'm reporting his project for being “too violent or scary” to see if mine is “too violent or scary” (people can't report mine because I already censored the project)

Last edited by sharkode (Oct. 25, 2021 23:23:50)

cheddargirl
Scratch Team
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

Even if a teddy bear is an inanimate object, the overall vibe of the project is pushing more into the realm of torture simulator as opposed to being a comical beat-up project, and the project would be unshared by a moderator on those grounds.
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

cheddargirl wrote:

Even if a teddy bear is an inanimate object, the overall vibe of the project is pushing more into the realm of torture simulator as opposed to being a comical beat-up project, and the project would be unshared by a moderator on those grounds.
I censored it already
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

cheddargirl wrote:

Even if a teddy bear is an inanimate object, the overall vibe of the project is pushing more into the realm of torture simulator as opposed to being a comical beat-up project, and the project would be unshared by a moderator on those grounds.
So how am I supposed to change it so it doesn't violate the rules anymore?
sharkode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is this type of 'violence' allowed?

cheddargirl wrote:

Even if a teddy bear is an inanimate object, the overall vibe of the project is pushing more into the realm of torture simulator as opposed to being a comical beat-up project, and the project would be unshared by a moderator on those grounds.
So how am I supposed to change it so it doesn't violate the rules anymore?

Powered by DjangoBB