Ivy_Zhangyanchu wrote:

Flowermanvista wrote:

Ivy_Zhangyanchu wrote:

Do you think it's possible to let every ST member upload these songs, listen to them, and mute these bad words every minute?

If that's the case, then we should also disable audio uploading in the Scratch editor to make sure nobody uploads a song with bad words in it.

I don't get what you are saying here. Disable audio uploading? I was talking about if it is disabled and you need to choose audio, but where do these audio come from? By millions of lines of code and uploads of these songs that the ST needs to do. Read my original post.

dertermenter wrote:

I think it's a cool idea but personalisation can be done in better ways. What happens if there is an annoying song playing? A song that makes you upset? I don't want to hear rickrolls on scratch 24/7 whilst I listen to amog us drip. This may have copyright issues, and scratch literally has a rule where you can't share projects where music is the main focus. This would make profiles have a massive focus on the music. I guess you could do sounds from scratch sound library, but that would kinda defeat the purpose as they basically just 10-20 second soundtracks.

Flowermanvista wrote:

Ivy_Zhangyanchu wrote:

Flowermanvista wrote:

Ivy_Zhangyanchu wrote:

Do you think it's possible to let every ST member upload these songs, listen to them, and mute these bad words every minute?

If that's the case, then we should also disable audio uploading in the Scratch editor to make sure nobody uploads a song with bad words in it.

I don't get what you are saying here. Disable audio uploading? I was talking about if it is disabled and you need to choose audio, but where do these audio come from? By millions of lines of code and uploads of these songs that the ST needs to do. Read my original post.

I guess I should clarify; what I meant is that the ST already gives you free reign to upload any audio you want into the editor without any form of automated screening - which is why report buttons exist. I don't see how being able to upload audio to your profile would be any different.

1. Do you know how many reports they should look into every day? Let's don't talk about the number and see how long it will take for the official SCC studio's spam comments to be deleted - 1 month.
   
2. Let's assume if the ST deal with one report in 10 minutes, there are now 10 reports after the ST starts to work and every minute there is one report (including mass reports) by average and after a minute, there are 11 reports, after 9 minutes, the first report is done but now nine reports came! So yes, after 10 minutes the ST starts working, there are 19 reports. It is hard to imagine how fast the report number grows. That's why Scratch has stuff like Filterbot - to avoid misuse of the reports.
   
3. By what I've said above, if every user has either an amazing or toxic song on their profile, and then Scratch has no deal with not only project reports, comment reports, forum reports, and also MOOSIC REPORTS. That's like dealing with 125% of reports more than now.
   
4. Some amazing and precious music with no bad words - have copyright. C-O-P-Y-R-I-G-H-T it's a serious thing. If Scratch has uploaded ALL SONGS they will receive thousands of emails.
   
5. Loudness and high-pitch (except for the sound bats makes which you cannot hear) are the two enemies of human ears. I think I don't have to explain.
   
6. Now let's talk about if it's disabled, the ST should Google a song, get copyright, and upload the songs faster than the speed of the wind. If you still don't understand, read my OP and my quote to Bedtime Math AGAIN.
   
7. It does not help with either creating, programming, or sharing - Scratch's motto.
   
8. What if a person who just want to quietly browse Scratch sites - and they go to their extroverted Scratch friend's profile, and suddenly, “hey I just met you and this is crazy” starts playing? This is like a jumpscqre.
   
9. I believe some people don't have a headphone - just like Chinese children don't have a Merry Christmas tree.
   

sukune wrote:

no support. reasons why:
1. COPYRIGHT- that will literally hunt scratch down
2. extra strain to servers, and plus it'll cost more to keep those up
3. inappropriate music/loud music would take forever to report because the ST receives many reports everyday
4. fanbases. reason why i say this is because there will be people falsely reporting someone's profile just because they hate the song
5. its not really educational or necessary

Ivy_Zhangyanchu wrote:

sukune wrote:

no support. reasons why:
1. COPYRIGHT- that will literally hunt scratch down
2. extra strain to servers, and plus it'll cost more to keep those up
3. inappropriate music/loud music would take forever to report because the ST receives many reports everyday
4. fanbases. reason why i say this is because there will be people falsely reporting someone's profile just because they hate the song
5. its not really educational or necessary

I agree. And someone would not like to hear music they HATE on another profile…

samq64 wrote:

Most browsers can't autoplay sound until the user interacts with the page.

BubblegumPop0204 wrote:

samq64 wrote:

Most browsers can't autoplay sound until the user interacts with the page.

MOST
Most browser, but Scratch could

Reev0102 wrote:

BubblegumPop0204 wrote:

samq64 wrote:

Most browsers can't autoplay sound until the user interacts with the page.

MOST
Most browser, but Scratch could

Scratch is not a browser.

BubblegumPop0204 wrote:

Reev0102 wrote:

BubblegumPop0204 wrote:

samq64 wrote:

Most browsers can't autoplay sound until the user interacts with the page.

MOST
Most browser, but Scratch could

Scratch is not a browser.

But a site, I meant
So it could support it!