Custom Profile/Studio comment emojis

kccuber

Chiroyce wrote:
mumu245 wrote:
But he added the no chrome emoji.
I support it - Google Chrome sucks.

yes of course

I_am_a_nerd28

I think custom emojis is a great idea. I support this post. A good idea is that New Scratchers can have emojis but not custom, only Scratchers can use the custom emoji feature. I hope the scratch team adds this!

mybearworld

kccuber wrote:
Chiroyce wrote:
mumu245 wrote:
But he added the no chrome emoji.
I support it - Google Chrome sucks.
yes of course

+1

anyways, this would be very interesting. Many users, and the majority of studios have themes, and custom emojis would be great for that. Honestly I'd just put more food emojis on my profile for food4food xD

kccuber

I_am_a_nerd28 wrote:
A good idea is that New Scratchers can have emojis but not custom, only Scratchers can use the custom emoji feature.

kccuber wrote:
The studio owner or the profile owner must be a Scratcher status

Yeah, I already mentioned that.

roketH77

This is a great idea! Now we can have mineral fish in comments!

god286

Yes I support. This will make the scratch profiles a lot better and it would add more personalisation to the profiles.

foressst

Wow! Support, it can customize your profile and studio much better.

Virus6120

No support. It's just another thing in need of moderation and I think the ST has enough on their hands already.

1Oaktree2

Semi-support. You see, while it is kinda pointless, and there is a way to send rude comments, what little kid wouldn't want to see their favourite character/OC/PFP/ in a comment?

mumu245 wrote:
Chiroyce wrote:
mumu245 wrote:
PLEASE DO NOT DO BROWSER DISCRIMINATION!
Where? He just gave an example for this studio
But he added the no chrome emoji.

That was an example. It's not discrimination, just because they had to pick one for an example

kccuber

bump because someone posted a dupe

VeryFamus

I mean, it would be cool to see your OC in an emoji for everyone to use, but let’s think practically for a second.

First of all, as mentioned, how would this be moderated? Would they have to be approved by the ST for use? Would you just have to report the emojis? Because this just seems like a giant mess to pile on to the already large pile of things to moderate. Plus, this would be the first introduction to actual images on the main site, which is typically easier to moderate on the forums.

Secondly, is this something you would have to upload to an image host, such as CupeUpload? Or is this just any random image that meets the file size requirements. If you can upload any random image, that would be even more moderation for the ST. If it was in CupeUpload or something like that, everybody is going to be making topics or emailing the ST about “why can’t I upload custom emojis?” “PLZ HELP my emojis no work” and more.

Third, here is more safety concern: the custom label that you have to type to write the emoji (e.g. _meow_)? It would be very difficult to find out what that label is, because all comments with the label- the label gets censored into an emoji! So it’s basically a guarantee to hide swear words from teh ST and more inappropriate stuff.

Overall, you can’t expect people to have the common sense and maturity to be able to handle this properly.

kccuber

VeryFamus wrote:
First of all, as mentioned, how would this be moderated? Would they have to be approved by the ST for use? Would you just have to report the emojis? Because this just seems like a giant mess to pile on to the already large pile of things to moderate. Plus, this would be the first introduction to actual images on the main site, which is typically easier to moderate on the forums.

Ok so first of all it's Scratchers only. Second, PFPs, projects and studio thumbnails already exist and that's a far easier way to post high quality inappropriate emojis than a tiny 64x64 square. Actual images, well, as I said, you forgot studio thumbnails, profile pictures, and projects.

VeryFamus wrote:
Secondly, is this something you would have to upload to an image host, such as CupeUpload? Or is this just any random image that meets the file size requirements. If you can upload any random image, that would be even more moderation for the ST. If it was in CupeUpload or something like that, everybody is going to be making topics or emailing the ST about “why can’t I upload custom emojis?” “PLZ HELP my emojis no work” and more.

No, this is uploaded to the main site on the assets server. We are not trying to kill cubeupload's servers.

VeryFamus wrote:
Third, here is more safety concern: the custom label that you have to type to write the emoji (e.g. _meow_)? It would be very difficult to find out what that label is, because all comments with the label- the label gets censored into an emoji! So it’s basically a guarantee to hide swear words from teh ST and more inappropriate stuff.

There is no label that you can manually type in, as shown on the example images. If there would be a label, it would probably be randomly generated like this:

username is ExampleUser - Emoji Label would be _exampleuser1_, _exampleuser2_ and so on

Studio ID is 3014863 (I made that ID up BTW) - Emoji label would be _3014863-1_, _3014863-2_ and so on

Last edited by kccuber (March 23, 2022 23:44:53)

kccuber

bump

jackson49

Bump

kccuber

bump

soarroying

Now, I'm going to put a spoiler in here. Trolls.
For one, those trolls could upload insanely inappropriate emojis, forcing the Scratch Team to temporarily disable comments.
For two, it could be #1, but combined with emoji spam
And of course, there should be an alert for spamming the emojis or posting insanely inappropriate emojis. If they continue to they will be banned!
EDIT: New Scratchers or users banned for hate using swearing {EG: (word censored by st, post will be eaten by an evil mango soon)} should be unable to use this.

Last edited by soarroying (May 13, 2022 00:52:45)

historical_supa

soarroying wrote:
Now, I'm going to put a spoiler in here. Trolls.
For one, those trolls could upload insanely inappropriate emojis, forcing the Scratch Team to temporarily disable comments.
For two, it could be #1, but combined with emoji spam
And of course, there should be an alert for spamming the emojis or posting insanely inappropriate emojis. If they continue to they will be IP banned!

Did you read the whole post?

soarroying

historical_supa wrote:
soarroying wrote:
Now, I'm going to put a spoiler in here. Trolls.
For one, those trolls could upload insanely inappropriate emojis, forcing the Scratch Team to temporarily disable comments.
For two, it could be #1, but combined with emoji spam
And of course, there should be an alert for spamming the emojis or posting insanely inappropriate emojis. If they continue to they will be IP banned!
Did you read the whole post?

Yes

historical_supa

soarroying wrote:
historical_supa wrote:
soarroying wrote:
Now, I'm going to put a spoiler in here. Trolls.
For one, those trolls could upload insanely inappropriate emojis, forcing the Scratch Team to temporarily disable comments.
For two, it could be #1, but combined with emoji spam
And of course, there should be an alert for spamming the emojis or posting insanely inappropriate emojis. If they continue to they will be IP banned!
Did you read the whole post?
Yes

Then I assume you have read this:

kccuber wrote:
Requirements:
Images should be less than or equal to 64x64px to prevent inappropriate emojis. The studio owner or the profile owner must be a Scratcher status, to further prevent inappropriate emojis (just like the forums)

This would stop most of the trolls.

Last edited by historical_supa (May 13, 2022 00:54:18)

Roblox888i

Chiroyce wrote:
mumu245 wrote:
But he added the no chrome emoji.
I support it - Google Chrome sucks.

Im forced to use it

My browser / operating system: ChromeOS 14469.59.0, Chrome 99.0.4844.94, No Flash version detected

Discuss Scratch