Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

gosoccerboy5 wrote:

Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

- only 25 posts per topic. “you are free to make a new topic at any time”

dhuls wrote:

Also:
- Open Source Projects, Developing Scratch Extensions, and Connecting to the Physical world merged with the Advanced Topics (good?)
- Advanced Topics possibly shutdown (bad)
- Things I'm Making and Creating, Things I'm Reading and Playing, and Show and Tell merged (bad)
- Requests, Collaboration, Project Ideas, and Help with Scripts merged (bad)
- Subcategories in the language forums (good)
- Language forums moved up (okay?)

Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

LegoManiac04 wrote:

dhuls wrote:

9gr wrote:

im hoping for forums update next year

The order is probably

1. Profiles
   
2. My Stuff
   
3. Miscellaneous (Cloudmonitor, statistics, etc.)
   
4. Forums
   

That would mean a new update every 3 months, which I would be fine if done right, but it would probably be rushed.

To be honest I doubt they'll mess anything else up. They did what they did with studios because of the problems they were posing on the performance and moderation side of things. The forums don't really have much of any issues, nor are they that hard to moderate, so I can't see much going wrong here.

LegoManiac04 wrote:

To be honest I doubt they'll mess anything else up. They did what they did with studios because of the problems they were posing on the performance and moderation side of things. The forums don't really have much of any issues, nor are they that hard to moderate, so I can't see much going wrong here.

Raihan142857 wrote:

dhuls wrote:

9gr wrote:

im hoping for forums update next year

The order is probably

1. Profiles
   
2. My Stuff
   
3. Miscellaneous (Cloudmonitor, statistics, etc.)
   
4. Forums
   

That would mean a new update every 3 months, which I would be fine if done right, but it would probably be rushed.

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

dhuls wrote:

LegoManiac04 wrote:

dhuls wrote:

9gr wrote:

im hoping for forums update next year

The order is probably

1. Profiles
   
2. My Stuff
   
3. Miscellaneous (Cloudmonitor, statistics, etc.)
   
4. Forums
   

That would mean a new update every 3 months, which I would be fine if done right, but it would probably be rushed.

To be honest I doubt they'll mess anything else up. They did what they did with studios because of the problems they were posing on the performance and moderation side of things. The forums don't really have much of any issues, nor are they that hard to moderate, so I can't see much going wrong here.

I honestly can't think of a way to mess up profiles and my stuff (except for hiding follower counts, but I think that's rejected)

lapisi wrote:

dhuls wrote:

LegoManiac04 wrote:

dhuls wrote:

9gr wrote:

im hoping for forums update next year

The order is probably

1. Profiles
   
2. My Stuff
   
3. Miscellaneous (Cloudmonitor, statistics, etc.)
   
4. Forums
   

That would mean a new update every 3 months, which I would be fine if done right, but it would probably be rushed.

To be honest I doubt they'll mess anything else up. They did what they did with studios because of the problems they were posing on the performance and moderation side of things. The forums don't really have much of any issues, nor are they that hard to moderate, so I can't see much going wrong here.

I honestly can't think of a way to mess up profiles and my stuff (except for hiding follower counts, but I think that's rejected)

no, it's actually partially accepted, the follower count is much harder to notice now

Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

scratchusername40 wrote:

They'll probably just move it to discourse or something like it and do some small changes

scratchusername40 wrote:

Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

They'll probably just move it to discourse or something like it and do some small changes

AmazingMech2418 wrote:

scratchusername40 wrote:

Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

They'll probably just move it to discourse or something like it and do some small changes

They probably wouldn't. They want everything on their website and likely won't move everything to another platform that's harder to moderate.

AmazingMech2418 wrote:

scratchusername40 wrote:

Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

They'll probably just move it to discourse or something like it and do some small changes

They probably wouldn't. They want everything on their website and likely won't move everything to another platform that's harder to moderate.

dhuls wrote:

AmazingMech2418 wrote:

scratchusername40 wrote:

Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

They'll probably just move it to discourse or something like it and do some small changes

They probably wouldn't. They want everything on their website and likely won't move everything to another platform that's harder to moderate.

They can host it themselves. Plus, Discourse is open source so they are probably gonna customize it heavily like they did with DjangoBB (and maybe FluxBB when 1.x used that)

kccuber wrote:

dhuls wrote:

AmazingMech2418 wrote:

scratchusername40 wrote:

Raihan142857 wrote:

A forums update would be terrible. This is what I guess will happen:
- You need to wait 5 minutes between posts
- You get muted for saying bad words that normally get censored with *s, and names of websites that you can't mention on the main website, like Discord
- Automatic post dustbinning
- Code tag will be removed
- The page is way too large and only can fit 5 posts

They'll probably just move it to discourse or something like it and do some small changes

They probably wouldn't. They want everything on their website and likely won't move everything to another platform that's harder to moderate.

They can host it themselves. Plus, Discourse is open source so they are probably gonna customize it heavily like they did with DjangoBB (and maybe FluxBB when 1.x used that)

i hope they don't use discourse as it has infinite scrolling and it seems more like an unmoderated chat site than a forum. heck even the regular forums without “”the extension“” look better than discourse
nodebb actually makes sense cause 2.0 = django (2.0 forums = djangobb) so 3.0 = node (3.0 forums would be nodebb)

Maximouse wrote:

I don't think the fact that NodeBB is written in the same language as their API makes it much more likely to be used.

Maximouse wrote:

I don't think the fact that NodeBB is written in the same language as their API makes it much more likely to be used.

AmazingMech2418 wrote:

Also, allows a lot of Scratch 3.0 tools to be integrated with the new forums easier. XD

AmazingMech2418 wrote:

Though, they can't really include muting here because there's the false mute forum topic.

ScratchCat wrote:

There will be a form built into the filterbot window to gather your thoughts and report mistakes.