Constructive Recommendations On How to Respond to and Make Suggestions!

ILoveGames999

Where do we suggest?

plqaokwsijeduhrfyg

ILoveGames999 wrote:
Where do we suggest?

You should see a new topic button at the top right of the page.
Edit: added image:

Last edited by plqaokwsijeduhrfyg (April 29, 2021 02:00:36)

Cupcake19880

This is so helpful! Thank you for making this sticky!

AryWiz

paccino wrote:
I agree with everything but your disagreement of “no support theres a workaround” thing because sometimes making things challenging would force kids to improve and become better programmers.

And you want them to be not good coders?

PGBFLITE6373

paccino wrote:
I agree with everything but your disagreement of “no support theres a workaround” thing because sometimes making things challenging would force kids to improve and become better programmers.

the idea falls apart with the glide block. Glide block has a workaround buts its hard to program. If a kid dosn't know how to make it, he looks it up.

koopafan21

New block:

jump () feet

plqaokwsijeduhrfyg

koopafan21 wrote:
New block:
jump () feet

Please create your own topic for your suggestion.

koopafan21

if clicked then move to position x: () y: ()

Last edited by koopafan21 (May 8, 2021 13:46:00)

ScratchCat1038

This is a little confusing for me:

The 6th Suggestion wrote:
Don't “No Support” a suggestion just because it has a workaround.

The 9th Suggestion wrote:
If you're suggesting a block, then make sure there aren't any workarounds for your block.

The first one says even if a block has a workaround, it's still a good suggestion.
The second one says that you shouldn't suggest a block with a workaround.

They kind of conflict. Can you clarify this for me? Thanks!

-ScratchCat1038

plqaokwsijeduhrfyg

koopafan21 wrote:

if clicked then move to position x: () y: ()

when this sprite clicked
go to x: () y: ()

koopafan21

when green flag clicked
ask [hi] and wait

ScratchCat1038

koopafan21 wrote:

when green flag clicked
ask [hi] and wait

Please do not blockspam.

00321020

I think it would be nice if you could pin comments (maybe asking for permission who sent it, but you should send nice comments anyways)

Queer_Royalty

00321020 wrote:
I think it would be nice if you could pin comments (maybe asking for permission who sent it, but you should send nice comments anyways)

Please make a separate topic for each of your suggestions, instead of posting here. (Also of course remember to check each of the stickies. In this case I think that suggestion is a duplicate.)

dhuls

ScratchCat1038 wrote:
This is a little confusing for me:
The 6th Suggestion wrote:
Don't “No Support” a suggestion just because it has a workaround.
The 9th Suggestion wrote:
If you're suggesting a block, then make sure there aren't any workarounds for your block.
The first one says even if a block has a workaround, it's still a good suggestion.
The second one says that you shouldn't suggest a block with a workaround.

They kind of conflict. Can you clarify this for me? Thanks!

-ScratchCat1038

If the workaround is simple (like forever if and not equal) don't suggest. Don't turn down suggestions for having workarounds unless the the workaround is simple.
If this guy is still active, this should be updated to say that just because a feature is in a Scratch mod (like Turbowarp), doesn't mean the suggestion is bad. Conversely, Scratch shouldn't add blocks just because they're in a mod.
Did you notice the second the?

ScratchCat1038

dhuls wrote:
ScratchCat1038 wrote:
This is a little confusing for me:
The 6th Suggestion wrote:
Don't “No Support” a suggestion just because it has a workaround.
The 9th Suggestion wrote:
If you're suggesting a block, then make sure there aren't any workarounds for your block.
The first one says even if a block has a workaround, it's still a good suggestion.
The second one says that you shouldn't suggest a block with a workaround.

They kind of conflict. Can you clarify this for me? Thanks!

-ScratchCat1038
If the workaround is simple (like forever if and not equal) don't suggest. Don't turn down suggestions for having workarounds unless the the workaround is simple.
If this guy is still active, this should be updated to say that just because a feature is in a Scratch mod (like Turbowarp), doesn't mean the suggestion is bad. Conversely, Scratch shouldn't add blocks just because they're in a mod.
Did you notice the second the?

Thanks!

H_Dur

this should be closed…. no discussion

han614698

H_Dur wrote:
this should be closed…. no discussion

+1 - sigton isn’t active to update it anymore.

ILikeProggraming123

H_Dur wrote:
this should be closed…. no discussion

+1 I have literally never seen a “there are new posts in this discussion” for this topic before today.

lapisi

ILikeProggraming123 wrote:
H_Dur wrote:
this should be closed…. no discussion
+1 I have literally never seen a “there are new posts in this discussion” for this topic before today.

+1 same

Discuss Scratch