Is it OK to share links to websites OUTSIDE of scratch that isn't considered chat?

thunderdiamondgem

I want to know if another website like canva or even your website? What about apps? How about extensions for chrome? Please answer! Tysm!!!!

thunderdiamondgem

Also cool signature, right?!

awesome-llama

Mostly, yes. If the content does not break Scratch's rules, then you can post the links here.

For canva, I have never heard of it and so I don't have experience with it. I can't say whether this one is allowed or not, you have to decide.
For your own website, yes, but make sure things like contact forms or commenting is not there (as this would be private messaging with no moderation).
Apps can be mentioned and websites can be linked.
But extensions, no. This announcement addresses it: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/284272/

-db

You can't link extensions. You can link youtube but usually links on forums will get converted. I do not know about other sites but I know some others are allowed. Also the yt links get converted so you can only see the video not the chat.

ScratchCatHELLO

Not really sure. Does canva have NSFW content at all?
If your website follows the scratch CGs and ToS, yes
Depends on what the app is
You cannot link, name, or discuss browser extensions, especially scratch-related browser extensions.

airplanedodge

ScratchCatHELLO wrote:
Not really sure. Does canva have NSFW content at all?

Uhh, if canva had nsfw content we would not have used it for school. Canva is a digital art website.

ScratchCatHELLO

airplanedodge wrote:
ScratchCatHELLO wrote:
Not really sure. Does canva have NSFW content at all?
Uhh, if canva had nsfw content we would not have used it for school. Canva is a digital art website.

I know that, but is it possible to share content that's inappropriate?

WindowsMeRules2000

Depends whether the site has inappropriate content.

mtech22

ScratchCatHELLO wrote:
airplanedodge wrote:
ScratchCatHELLO wrote:
Not really sure. Does canva have NSFW content at all?
Uhh, if canva had nsfw content we would not have used it for school. Canva is a digital art website.

I know that, but is it possible to share content that's inappropriate?

You can upload images to it, however I have no idea if there is any thing in their terms stating you cannot upload inappropriate images. However I doubt they would be in the pre loaded image library

thunderdiamondgem

its just a drawing website :3

Austinato

I believe it's fine to share website links as long as that site is child-friendly and has no live features (this includes live drawing, live streaming, etc.) If the website contains Discord links or personal info belonging to any Scratch user, then I don't think it's allowed. For example, a link to the site for The Forum Helpers (a group of Scratchers, non ST members) is allowed to be shared on this site.

Canva should be fine since its main purpose is to serve as an individual workspace for producing content. Just don't share any live editing or collaboration links if those exist.

Last edited by Austinato (May 1, 2021 03:07:05)

dhuls

airplanedodge wrote:
ScratchCatHELLO wrote:
Not really sure. Does canva have NSFW content at all?
Uhh, if canva had nsfw content we would not have used it for school. Canva is a digital art website.

Canva is like Google Docs and therefore shouldn't be allowed on Scratch.

Last edited by dhuls (May 1, 2021 03:17:31)

Scratch137

Are we thinking of the same Canva here…? If so, it's NOT a digital art website. It's a graphic design tool intended for creating things like business cards and flyers.

A quick Bing search (keep your mouth shut) led me to Canva's Terms of Use, which contains the following information:

4.2 Uploading and Publishing User Content to Canva

You agree not to submit or use User Content that: (…) seeks to harm or exploit children by exposing them to inappropriate content, asking for personally identifiable details or otherwise;

According to their terms, Canva does not allow content specifically made to be harmful to or exploitative of children.
However, another paragraph in the same section states:

You understand and agree that you may be exposed to User Content or Stock Media that is inaccurate, objectionable, inappropriate for children, or otherwise unsuited to your purpose, and you agree that Canva shall not be liable for any damages you allege to incur as a result of User Content, Stock Media or your use of either in printed form.

So I'd say it's a bit of a grey area. While Canva does prohibit the posting of content specifically made to harm or exploit children, there do not seem to be any explicit measures put in place to prevent inappropriate content from being posted in general. Keep in mind that Canva allows users to upload their own images for use in designs.

I'd advise that you just be careful, and maybe don't link to anything on Canva until a Scratch Team member gives the all-clear.

Last edited by Scratch137 (May 1, 2021 04:29:55)

samq64

I think so, because there are three external links in my About Me and What I'm Working On and I haven't got any alert.

You are not, however allowed to link browser extensions.

Last edited by samq64 (May 1, 2021 14:44:12)

hiPeeps124816

Extensions aren't allowed, but others are.

PaddlerGames

Yes, you can give links to websites outside of scratch, unless the website has unmoderated chat, browser extensions, live streaming, or any other inappropriate stuff.

thunderdiamondgem

ohh, ok. Tysm!

Harakou

thunderdiamondgem wrote:
ohh, ok. Tysm!

Glad you found an answer! Since this is resolved, I'll close it to help highlight the answer and prevent future responses. If you need it re-opened, though, you can report this and ask.

Discuss Scratch