Discuss Scratch

CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

please read what @9gr said about cryptocurrencies as this post says it's not allowed

9gr wrote:

No, I was in a collab few days ago and it got shut down; it was a cryptocurrency in scratch.

Paddle2See wrote:

I really don't think this is a good fit for Scratch. If you are going to go to the trouble of limiting distribution and enforcing use, then it has some sort of value and goes against the policy.
DipLeChip
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

CoolLionMan wrote:

please read what @9gr said about cryptocurrencies as this post says it's not allowed

9gr wrote:

No, I was in a collab few days ago and it got shut down; it was a cryptocurrency in scratch.

Paddle2See wrote:

I really don't think this is a good fit for Scratch. If you are going to go to the trouble of limiting distribution and enforcing use, then it has some sort of value and goes against the policy.

I actually have experience so no read mine lol

DipLeChip wrote:

Last time this was done it went downhill, this about a year or two ago (late late 2018 to early 2019) and the dominant one that eventually died off was ShopBux.
there were a few controversies with paying for loves and faves and I believe outright denying services if not payed (citation needed). With this the ST had to enforce a few rules where you may not be denied service if you don't pay, may not be allowed to buy loves, fave and follows from the currency and a few more things you can find here: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/340012/

This topic is in pretty murky waters, and is generally considered not a good idea. You can still go ahead with it if you follow said rules in that post tho. But you can't really do much with the currency anyway.

Last edited by DipLeChip (March 4, 2021 00:02:04)

kasyanthecat
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

9gr wrote:

No, I was in a collab few days ago and it got shut down; it was a cryptocurrency in scratch.

Paddle2See wrote:

I really don't think this is a good fit for Scratch. If you are going to go to the trouble of limiting distribution and enforcing use, then it has some sort of value and goes against the policy.
This won't violate Paddle's rules, because there will not be limited distribution. The coin will just get harder to mine the more there are users online. No enforcing use either. There will be a rule: No making pay-to-play games. This will get us banned and no one will have fun.
kasyanthecat
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

kasyanthecat wrote:

9gr wrote:

No, I was in a collab few days ago and it got shut down; it was a cryptocurrency in scratch.

Paddle2See wrote:

I really don't think this is a good fit for Scratch. If you are going to go to the trouble of limiting distribution and enforcing use, then it has some sort of value and goes against the policy.
This won't violate Paddle's rules, because there will not be limited distribution. The coin will just get harder to mine the more there are users online. No enforcing use either. There will be a rule: No making pay-to-play games. This will get us banned and no one will have fun.
Of course no paying with loves and faves. This is kinda illegal.
yippymishy
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

To Do
  • Name
  • Logo
  • Studio
  • Get People To Use It
  • Value
  • Bank (?)
kasyanthecat
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

yippymishy wrote:

To Do
  • Name
  • Logo
  • Studio
  • Get People To Use It
  • Value
  • Bank (?)
Sooooo…
Name: Scratchcoin? Scratchtoken?
  • Logo: A golden Scratch Cat on a coin?
  • Studio: Well we can just create it
  • Get people to use it: Oh… No ideas
  • Value: increases over time (the more users are online, the more you have to wait to mine one coin)
  • Bank: An encrypted cloud list that has username/money amount/password in one string, encrypted by @dixiklo 's free encoder/decoder and then ran through my Very Special Numbers To Weird Unicode Symbols Converter™(in development). The encrypting codes will change monthly for safety reasons. All the people who use the Scratchcoin Game Donate API™(also in development) will be notified to check for the new codes or else the system won't work.

Last edited by kasyanthecat (March 4, 2021 17:00:25)

yippymishy
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

kasyanthecat wrote:

yippymishy wrote:

-snip-
Sooooo…
Name: Scratchcoin? Scratchtoken?
Logo: A golden Scratch Cat on a coin?
Studio: Well we can just create it
Get people to use it: Oh… No ideas
Value: increases over time (the more users are online, the more you have to wait to mine one coin)
Bank: An encrypted cloud list that has username/money amount/password in one string, encrypted by @dixiclo ‘s free encoder/decoder and then ran through my Very Special Numbers To Weird Unicode Symbols Converter™(in development). The encrypting codes will change monthly for safety reasons. All the people who use the Scratchcoin Game Donate API™(also in development) will be notified to check for the new codes or else the system won’t work.
Wow, all sounds good. For the name, maybe CatCoin? BlockToken? CodeCoin? As for the logo, maybe the Scratch Cat like you said, or a Scratch Block. Tell me which you like best. I'll invite you to the studio and make you manager.

Last edited by yippymishy (March 4, 2021 17:03:01)

-Quantum_Studios-
Scratcher
500+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

Count me in! We should make a Collabs topic now.
yippymishy
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

-Quantum_Studios- wrote:

Count me in! We should make a Collabs topic now.

OK, you can do that. I'll invite you to the studio.
-Quantum_Studios-
Scratcher
500+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

yippymishy wrote:

-Quantum_Studios- wrote:

Count me in! We should make a Collabs topic now.

OK, you can do that. I'll invite you to the studio.
Is it officially called Scratchcoin?
kasyanthecat
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

-Quantum_Studios- wrote:

yippymishy wrote:

-Quantum_Studios- wrote:

Count me in! We should make a Collabs topic now.

OK, you can do that. I'll invite you to the studio.
Is it officially called Scratchcoin?
I think so. Scratchtoken sounds kinda stupid.
imfh
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

You might want to make a new topic in Collaboration so this one doesn't get closed for not being about a question anymore.
SlenTheOoof
Scratcher
93 posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

Allowed probably, but would be hard to keep track of. You'd have to do some fancy encrypting.
TopCode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

see, the problem with crypto as opposed to say ‘vbucks’ is price fluctuation, a vbuck isnt gonna change value because its set, cryptocurrencies dont work like that, so if “scratchcoin” crashes then people will lose value. and im not sure how you would keep track of it with blockchain in scratch, idk it seems like it could go downhill.

is it gonna be like an external program? or some sort of scratch project?
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

I’m reporting this to be moved to collaborations
-Quantum_Studios-
Scratcher
500+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

CoolLionMan wrote:

I’m reporting this to be moved to collaborations
Actually, there's already a topic for that.
kasyanthecat
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

TopCode wrote:

see, the problem with crypto as opposed to say ‘vbucks’ is price fluctuation, a vbuck isnt gonna change value because its set, cryptocurrencies dont work like that, so if “scratchcoin” crashes then people will lose value. and im not sure how you would keep track of it with blockchain in scratch, idk it seems like it could go downhill.

is it gonna be like an external program? or some sort of scratch project?
Not quite sure how will price fluctuation work, I was thinking M=t*(a:10) Where M is the time needed to mine 1 coin, t is the amount of wait time set in the project (say 5 seconds or more) and a is the amount of users online right now. If a/10 < 0, then M=t.

There will be a monitoring system: you choose what game will you donate to and how much money, and it gives out a “talon” (talons are basically save-codes) which has, along with the amount of money, the game's name in it. After the transaction, the game puts the talon's id in a cloud list in NOTBAD (Not Offline Transaction Basic API for Donations). If you put the talon in again it will say you already used it. If you put it in a different game, it'll just say the talon's not for this game.

Last edited by kasyanthecat (March 5, 2021 15:02:19)

kasyanthecat
Scratcher
100+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

Where in the world is the Scratchcoin topic in collabs? Is this dead? What happened?
Shajiui_Da_Black_Fox
Scratcher
500+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

kasyanthecat wrote:

Where in the world is the Scratchcoin topic in collabs? Is this dead? What happened?

This hasn't been moved to collabs yet.
roketH77
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Is creating cryptocurrencies allowed on Scratch? (NOT INVOLVING REAL MONEY)

kasyanthecat wrote:

Thanks for the advice! I'll start making a collab dedicated to the creating of the cryptocurrency soon! You are all invited if you want!
Yes please!

Powered by DjangoBB