Discuss Scratch

PicoMetrics
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Green Flag Suggestion

the2000 wrote:

PicoMetrics wrote:

New scratchers aren't always new
If I made a new account, I don't think I'd lose sleep over an extra green flag in the coding section that I may or may not use
It just seems like another thing adding to the assumption that all new scratchers are new. No offense meant to the ST
the2000
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Green Flag Suggestion

PicoMetrics wrote:

the2000 wrote:

PicoMetrics wrote:

New scratchers aren't always new
If I made a new account, I don't think I'd lose sleep over an extra green flag in the coding section that I may or may not use
It just seems like another thing adding to the assumption that all new scratchers are new. No offense meant to the ST
Do you think that anyone making an alt would be seriously offended by the assumption that they're a new user? We shouldn't remove any New Scratcher spam prevention methods just because “it would be rude to assume that they're a new user,” so why is it a reason not to support this?
PicoMetrics
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Green Flag Suggestion

the2000 wrote:

PicoMetrics wrote:

the2000 wrote:

PicoMetrics wrote:

New scratchers aren't always new
If I made a new account, I don't think I'd lose sleep over an extra green flag in the coding section that I may or may not use
It just seems like another thing adding to the assumption that all new scratchers are new. No offense meant to the ST
Do you think that anyone making an alt would be seriously offended by the assumption that they're a new user? We shouldn't remove any New Scratcher spam prevention methods just because “it would be rude to assume that they're a new user,” so why is it a reason not to support this?
Actually, I'm the owner of the topic's alt. I am used to the spam prevention stuff and agree that they have a good point, but the suggestion that someone had for this just took it too far that only new scratchers would do this.
the2000
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Green Flag Suggestion

PicoMetrics wrote:

the2000 wrote:

PicoMetrics wrote:

It just seems like another thing adding to the assumption that all new scratchers are new. No offense meant to the ST
Do you think that anyone making an alt would be seriously offended by the assumption that they're a new user? We shouldn't remove any New Scratcher spam prevention methods just because “it would be rude to assume that they're a new user,” so why is it a reason not to support this?
Actually, I'm the owner of the topic's alt. I am used to the spam prevention stuff and agree that they have a good point, but the suggestion that someone had for this just took it too far that only new scratchers would do this.
I never said you weren't? And how is automatically putting a green flag in the script area “taking it too far that only new scratchers would do this”?
PkmnQ
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Green Flag Suggestion

PicoMetrics wrote:

the2000 wrote:

PicoMetrics wrote:

New scratchers aren't always new
If I made a new account, I don't think I'd lose sleep over an extra green flag in the coding section that I may or may not use
It just seems like another thing adding to the assumption that all new scratchers are new. No offense meant to the ST

Well, I don't think that this would happen.

Someone's alt wrote:

OMG Scrach teem put green flag!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111!!!! RUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUDE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111!!!!oneeleven!!!!!!!!!

No, they'd just start placing blocks and going on with the project. So I think it doesn't matter that it adds to the assumption, it doesn't offend anybody.

That being said, I think having it restricted to new scratchers is a bit weird, and it might actually be counterproductive to learning. An actually new New Scratcher would automatically have the green flag, so they wouldn't learn where the flag was. When they become a Scratcher, the atuomatic green flag gets removed. Cue confusion. This also applies to a lesser extent the original suggestion, so no support to that one as well.

Last edited by PkmnQ (Jan. 6, 2021 04:47:30)

PicoMetrics
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Green Flag Suggestion

bump

Powered by DjangoBB