Add Forums Stats in the "Statistics" Section

sportfan999

sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
So more people can see this, I'm going to Bring Up My Post!

sportfan999

sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
So more people can see this, I'm going to Bring Up My Post!

sportfan999

sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
sportfan999 wrote:
So more people can see this, I'm going to Bring Up My Post!

Paddle2See

This would be a cool feature - I would be interested to see how the forum-using community is growing as well.

My concern is, even if forum metrics were accepted as a feature, it is such a small part of the Scratch universe that I doubt it would get a very high priority from the developers. There's a lot that needs to be done.

I will leave this open for now so that the suggestion can be further refined - and we'll see if there is interest from the rest of the team.

sportfan999

Bump

Tunde123

I sometime wonder how the forums are holding up. But I never get to see how they are holding up. Support!

Ihatr

Bump

sportfan999

Thanksgiving bump

IndianRuby718

Yesss more data! Also nice mockup, I like it! Support!

fdreerf wrote:
Average Daily Posts, Average Daily Users, New Forumers in the Last Month

pandacorn_owl wrote:
I think maybe the average posts per topic could have a category for each forum then a category for all.

If the ST implements this, then it wouldn't feel right for it to be so specific for the forums when for the rest of the site it's very general. Especially about the activity of users I think so much more could be added there. Maybe for now it could be the forums in general? (but still good to discuss :P)

pandacorn_owl wrote:
I'm also not to sure about average posts per topic as there will be lots of low post count topics and a couple large post count topics that could make the average quite a strange number.

Agreed. Strange as in inaccurate, since there's a big gap in the middle and taking an average wouldn't make sense at all. That's why I think instead there should be a graph for OP:Post ratio to users with that ratio! So we can see how diverse each user is getting among the topics, if they post frequently in the same topics or spread out more. Since 1:1 is the limit that should probably be the start of the graph, and the posts per topic for a user go up in the graph. This would be much more useful and accurate imo with a good general overview.
[oh wow it turned the ":P“ in ”OP:Post" into the emoji XD]

lm1996 wrote:
I think that strange number would be quite interesting.

XD true, but not displayed on the official statistics page.

TheAdriCoolManDude

Support, as someone who likes looking at data, this info would be really interesting to me.

fdreerf

IndianRuby718 wrote:
fdreerf wrote:
Average Daily Posts, Average Daily Users, New Forumers in the Last Month
pandacorn_owl wrote:
I think maybe the average posts per topic could have a category for each forum then a category for all.
If the ST implements this, then it wouldn't feel right for it to be so specific for the forums when for the rest of the site it's very general. Especially about the activity of users I think so much more could be added there. Maybe for now it could be the forums in general? (but still good to discuss :P)

I don't see how those three things are too specific.

IndianRuby718

fdreerf wrote:
IndianRuby718 wrote:
fdreerf wrote:
Average Daily Posts, Average Daily Users, New Forumers in the Last Month
pandacorn_owl wrote:
I think maybe the average posts per topic could have a category for each forum then a category for all.
If the ST implements this, then it wouldn't feel right for it to be so specific for the forums when for the rest of the site it's very general. Especially about the activity of users I think so much more could be added there. Maybe for now it could be the forums in general? (but still good to discuss :P)
I don't see how those three things are too specific.

I'm not saying they're too specific, but compared to the graphs already in place on the statistics page they are.
edit: badly worded post XP they're good ideas, and I do think they should be added, but I feel like they should add more stats about user activity first.

Last edited by IndianRuby718 (Dec. 21, 2020 21:05:13)

gosoccerboy5

Support. It's not like the forums don't exist — tell that to @fdeerf

Vaibhs11

Support! It would be cool

IndianRuby718

More Ideas: Posted topics to followed topics, and open to closed topics [bump]

Ihatr

Bump

Ihatr

bump

ForumHelperNanoPiex

Support! I'd love to see how the forums grow overtime!

-PhoenixAnimates-

Support, this would be useful for curious users.

Vaibhs11

This forum has finally reawaken

Discuss Scratch