MTM828 wrote:

TapingAnimations wrote:

MTM828 wrote:

3.shops are places where you ask for stuff, while requests are people asking for them without the order forms, terms, codewords, billions of banners and pictures etc.

They sound pretty much the same tho

Lemme just explain it more, once, i made a request, i wanted a few sounds so my games look more alive, so i made a request, when i come back soon, i see it waaaaay behind, i had to bump it, and bump it, and bump it without a rest, so i gave the link to a shop dude, the dude in the shop called it advertising and said it wasnt in the form of an order, so i had to put it in an order form, but gave up as that wasted a lot of valuable time. So u can see why requests are just as important.

TapingAnimations wrote:

Here's the thing that happened to me: I ordered at a shop one day for a banner and they gave it to me in less than 10 hours (Probably 5, idk)

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

TapingAnimations wrote:

Here's the thing that happened to me: I ordered at a shop one day for a banner and they gave it to me in less than 10 hours (Probably 5, idk)

It's not like shops would magically disappear.

TapingAnimations wrote:

And btw when I made an actual request in the Requests Forums it was there for like 3-4 hours

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

TapingAnimations wrote:

And btw when I made an actual request in the Requests Forums it was there for like 3-4 hours

that's just being lucky

_ReykjaviK_ wrote:

What is the issue? Shops are cool, I used to run one.

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

_ReykjaviK_ wrote:

What is the issue? Shops are cool, I used to run one.

the suggestion isn't to remove shops
its to let people actually make their own topics in requests without being brought down by the constant bumping of shops

also, shops are inconvenient compared to just making your own topic

MTM828 wrote:

I might add in a few things we can get as much use of this thread as possible. Thanks for your time! All opinions are welcome.
I've noticed that one of you Called me stubborn last time, and I'm sure that the Scratch Team saw it, plus the “person” was a forum helper, I'm not so happy about this.

MTM828 wrote:

TapingAnimations wrote:

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

TapingAnimations wrote:

TapingAnimations from last topic wrote:

No support, Shops are very good, they're the one that helped me in many stuff in Scratch (Including my old sig, my collabs logo, my old pfp, etc.) and I wouldn't want it gone, do you realize how many shops there are? Many shop-workers (Including me) work hard to make their customer happy, spending hours and even days to make the customers request(s), and if they're remove many Scratchers will be sad because all their hard work is gone, it's not a good idea imo, plus even if you make a request in the Request Forums all you'll get is Shop Owners posting in your topic: “You can get one here!” or “Come to my shop to buy it!”, Shops are a very simple thing, it's nothing complicated.

I don't think this is about removing shops.

Then what is it suggesting? What issue should they fix?

You're not so welcome here since you're being slightly rude, please, be co-operative here.

MTM828 wrote:

well, since we're here to chat about this, we can find a solution that way, so don't tell me i don't have a solution, help us come up with one.

MTM828 wrote:

When metch suddenly joined when he had something to say

MTM828 wrote:

and pvcato (i think thats his name) joins the chat suddenly too, im feeling like m being stocked, then you mass report me for some reason. next time just warn me k? that way i wont repeat the same mistake! also, ill edit this if it counts as name calling

MTM828 wrote:

TapingAnimations wrote:

MTM828 wrote:

3.shops are places where you ask for stuff, while requests are people asking for them without the order forms, terms, codewords, billions of banners and pictures etc.

They sound pretty much the same tho

Lemme just explain it more, once, i made a request, i wanted a few sounds so my games look more alive, so i made a request, when i come back soon, i see it waaaaay behind, i had to bump it, and bump it, and bump it without a rest, so i gave the link to a shop dude, the dude in the shop called it advertising and said it was'nt in the form of an order, so i had to put it in an order form, but gave up as that wasted a lot of valuable time. So u can see why requests are just as important.

MTM828 wrote:

Well, aren't some of the people from my old topic going to join? D <– train of smiles

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

TapingAnimations wrote:

And btw when I made an actual request in the Requests Forums it was there for like 3-4 hours

that's just being lucky

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

_ReykjaviK_ wrote:

What is the issue? Shops are cool, I used to run one.

the suggestion isn't to remove shops
its to let people actually make their own topics in requests without being brought down by the constant bumping of shops

also, shops are inconvenient compared to just making your own topic

cheddargirl wrote:

So, we're getting some confusion about the purpose of the “Requests” thread, and finding a lot of threads being misplaced here. Scimonster made a huge helpful list about which requests go where, so I'm reposting it (with a few edits so it fits the current 2.0 forums). Hopefully this topic will clear up which requests goes where. :)

• Help with Scripts — Requesting help with your scripts
  
• Show and Tell — Requesting views and/or feedback on a project and/or studio (formerly called a “gallery”)
  
• Project Ideas — Requesting ideas and/or feedback on ideas for projects
  
• Collaboration — Requesting members for your collaboration, and other things with collaborations (although advanced collaborations go in Advanced Topics)
  
• Requests — Requesting media like a signature, music, or art; creating a request shop for those items

JPOWERPUFFGIRLS wrote:

cheddargirl wrote:

So, we're getting some confusion about the purpose of the “Requests” thread, and finding a lot of threads being misplaced here. Scimonster made a huge helpful list about which requests go where, so I'm reposting it (with a few edits so it fits the current 2.0 forums). Hopefully this topic will clear up which requests goes where. :)

• Help with Scripts — Requesting help with your scripts
  
• Show and Tell — Requesting views and/or feedback on a project and/or studio (formerly called a “gallery”)
  
• Project Ideas — Requesting ideas and/or feedback on ideas for projects
  
• Collaboration — Requesting members for your collaboration, and other things with collaborations (although advanced collaborations go in Advanced Topics)
  
• Requests — Requesting media like a signature, music, or art; creating a request shop for those items

(Source)

MTM828_test wrote:

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

_ReykjaviK_ wrote:

What is the issue? Shops are cool, I used to run one.

the suggestion isn't to remove shops
its to let people actually make their own topics in requests without being brought down by the constant bumping of shops

also, shops are inconvenient compared to just making your own topic

Sorry guys but I was banned, apparently for being mean. Although I can't see where, I'm sorry. But you can see that I've changed, that's why I try to add these smileys and (try) to add humour. But fine, I'm sorry.

FloralAnimator wrote:

MTM828_test wrote:

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

_ReykjaviK_ wrote:

What is the issue? Shops are cool, I used to run one.

the suggestion isn't to remove shops
its to let people actually make their own topics in requests without being brought down by the constant bumping of shops

also, shops are inconvenient compared to just making your own topic

Sorry guys but I was banned, apparently for being mean. Although I can't see where, I'm sorry. But you can see that I've changed, that's why I try to add these smileys and (try) to add humour. But fine, I'm sorry.

Your ban evading.

Bluebatstar wrote:

FloralAnimator wrote:

MTM828_test wrote:

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

_ReykjaviK_ wrote:

What is the issue? Shops are cool, I used to run one.

the suggestion isn't to remove shops
its to let people actually make their own topics in requests without being brought down by the constant bumping of shops

also, shops are inconvenient compared to just making your own topic

Sorry guys but I was banned, apparently for being mean. Although I can't see where, I'm sorry. But you can see that I've changed, that's why I try to add these smileys and (try) to add humour. But fine, I'm sorry.

Your ban evading.

I think they meant a temporary ban. The other topic, the one I think they said they got banned from, was on the same account. I think they meant they got temporary banned, and the ban is now over.

JPOWERPUFFGIRLS wrote:

Bluebatstar wrote:

FloralAnimator wrote:

MTM828_test wrote:

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

_ReykjaviK_ wrote:

What is the issue? Shops are cool, I used to run one.

the suggestion isn't to remove shops
its to let people actually make their own topics in requests without being brought down by the constant bumping of shops

also, shops are inconvenient compared to just making your own topic

Sorry guys but I was banned, apparently for being mean. Although I can't see where, I'm sorry. But you can see that I've changed, that's why I try to add these smileys and (try) to add humour. But fine, I'm sorry.

Your ban evading.

I think they meant a temporary ban. The other topic, the one I think they said they got banned from, was on the same account. I think they meant they got temporary banned, and the ban is now over.

Don't temp bans take 3,5 days or longer

p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p- wrote:

After thinking really hard about this, I think I have made my decision. I think that instead, shops can only be bumped to the top of the 2nd page. When you create or edit the OP, it will give you the option to sign as a shop. If you create a shop without signing, a moderator would do it for you, and not with a smile.

Bluebatstar wrote:

FloralAnimator wrote:

MTM828_test wrote:

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:

_ReykjaviK_ wrote:

What is the issue? Shops are cool, I used to run one.

the suggestion isn't to remove shops
its to let people actually make their own topics in requests without being brought down by the constant bumping of shops

also, shops are inconvenient compared to just making your own topic

Sorry guys but I was banned, apparently for being mean. Although I can't see where, I'm sorry. But you can see that I've changed, that's why I try to add these smileys and (try) to add humour. But fine, I'm sorry.

Your ban evading.

I think they meant a temporary ban. The other topic, the one I think they said they got banned from, was on the same account. I think they meant they got temporary banned, and the ban is now over.

Bluebatstar wrote:

I agree with you saying that Shops kind of take up the entire Requests forum. I agree with a way to get actual requests noticed, but how would the Scratch Team do this? What @Paddle2See meant by ‘Be More Specific’ is that you are only suggesting the Scratch Team fix the issue, but you aren't actually explaining how they would do that, which is what the ST wants you to do.

(By the way, you are being Nice and Respectful here. Good job!)

PkmnQ wrote:

JPOWERPUFFGIRLS wrote:

cheddargirl wrote:

So, we're getting some confusion about the purpose of the “Requests” thread, and finding a lot of threads being misplaced here. Scimonster made a huge helpful list about which requests go where, so I'm reposting it (with a few edits so it fits the current 2.0 forums). Hopefully this topic will clear up which requests goes where. :)

• Help with Scripts — Requesting help with your scripts
  
• Show and Tell — Requesting views and/or feedback on a project and/or studio (formerly called a “gallery”)
  
• Project Ideas — Requesting ideas and/or feedback on ideas for projects
  
• Collaboration — Requesting members for your collaboration, and other things with collaborations (although advanced collaborations go in Advanced Topics)
  
• Requests — Requesting media like a signature, music, or art; creating a request shop for those items

(Source)

That doesn't mean it can't change.

Just because I say a stoplight is red doesn't mean it stays red forever.