ThatOneWeirdDude wrote:

Action was my favorite. IT kept all the good characters from season 1, and then put them in a whole new batch of creative challenges. The drama was great. I also loved all the character love drama, really put some spice on TD.

i liked action too

swiftrush wrote:

KingxDylan wrote:

ThatOneWeirdDude wrote:

Action was my favorite. IT kept all the good characters from season 1, and then put them in a whole new batch of creative challenges. The drama was great. I also loved all the character love drama, really put some spice on TD.

i liked action too

Action was just boring. It derailed a bunch of amazing characters - Leshawna used to be loyal and a great friend but in Action she was made into a much meaner person. Heather used to be a villainous mean girl but in Action she has no relevance on the show. Also even the characters that didn't get derailed were bad. Justin was so annoying, and Beth was just irritating. Speaking of Beth, she shouldn't have won. We all know the finale should've been Duncan vs Lindsay. It's just a fact.


rant done

o k b ut other than derailments its good.

Bridgette in Island: A nice person who was a good competitor.
Bridgette in Action: Literally just kisses Geoff all the time.
Bridgette in World Tour: Easily manipulated and didn't even have much of a purpose in being a competitor anyways.

TBH, it's sad how they handled Bridgette's character.

cheesyfriedeggs wrote:

Bridgette in Island: A nice person who was a good competitor.
Bridgette in Action: Literally just kisses Geoff all the time.
Bridgette in World Tour: Easily manipulated and didn't even have much of a purpose in being a competitor anyways.

TBH, it's sad how they handled Bridgette's character.

lol u be spitting the FACTS

bump

After watching just one episode, I made an RP about it on scratch. It's a little different from the shows but overall its total drama island.
P.S My fave character is heather

swiftrush wrote:

ok so i made two polls

https://strawpoll.com/hwak89dy
https://strawpoll.com/s1w992zc

Favorite season: TDROTI
Favorite character: Bridgette

swiftrush wrote:

lol so sorry for reviving this again but yesterday i sat down and made my own version of total drama all stars because our actual all stars sucks and it's really weird but just hear me out

Contestants: Lindsay, Zoey, Scott, Heather, Leshawna, Dawn, Izzy, Courtney, Gwen, Duncan, Mike, Cameron, Jo, Lightning, Owen, Alejandro, Beth, Harold

so i had this idea that they would start off merged - like not on teams. so this is the elimination order for that:

18th: Harold - quit to save leshawna from elimination
17th: Beth - voted out
16th: Alejandro - voted out
15th: Owen - voted out

so here is where i would bring in the teams, and the reason i started merged is so the teams would be even because i wanted to do old people vs new people instead of heroes vs villains

so here are the teams

old vultures: lindsay, heather, leshawna, izzy, courtney, gwen, duncan
new hamsters: zoey, scott, dawn, mike, cameron, jo, lightning

okay so from here this is the elimination order:

14th: lightning - eliminated by jo who threw the challenge but used the chris head immunity thing so lightning got eliminated
13th - jo - voted out
12th - cameron - it was a race to the finish line and cameron was last
11th - mike - dawn used the immunity head to eliminate mije
10th - duncan - voted out
9th - gwen - eliminated by chris

MERGE

8th - courtney - voted out
7th: izzy - voted out

ok so then i had this idea to unmerge them into different teams so that the losing team would battle and someone would get eliminated

UNMERGE

new teams:
villainous vultures - scott and heather
average people (havent figured out the name yet lol) - leshawna, dawn
heroic hamsters - lindsay, zoey

6th - dawn - eliminated by tiebreaker with leshawna
5th - leshawna - lost the challenge and there was no one else on her team
4th - heather - she won the tiebreaker but scott used the immunity head thing
3rd - scott - he lost the challenge and there was no one on his team

okay so

MERGE

so this is the finale
lindsay vs zoey

so i decided the main winner is lindsay and the alternate is zoey, but because they're nice people in both endings they split the million with eachother so

1st/2nd - zoey
1st/2nd - lindsay

so this is the final order

18th - Harold
17th - Beth
16th - Alejandro
15th - Owen
14th - Lightning
13th - Jo
12th - Cameron
11th - Mike
10th - Duncan
9th - Gwen
8th - Courtney
7th - Izzy
6th - Dawn
5th - Leshawna
4th - Heather
3rd - Scott
1st/2nd - Zoey
1st/2nd - Lindsay

what do yall think?

This is pretty cool, maybe you could call the average people the “Neutral Newts” (I thought of that on the spot)

swiftrush wrote:

ok so i made two polls

https://strawpoll.com/hwak89dy
https://strawpoll.com/s1w992zc

i chose world tour and heather

vicuna201 wrote:

After watching just one episode, I made an RP about it on scratch. It's a little different from the shows but overall its total drama island.
P.S My fave character is heather

i agree she's also my favorite, heather is a great villian

swiftrush wrote:

lol so sorry for reviving this again but yesterday i sat down and made my own version of total drama all stars because our actual all stars sucks and it's really weird but just hear me out

Contestants: Lindsay, Zoey, Scott, Heather, Leshawna, Dawn, Izzy, Courtney, Gwen, Duncan, Mike, Cameron, Jo, Lightning, Owen, Alejandro, Beth, Harold

so i had this idea that they would start off merged - like not on teams. so this is the elimination order for that:

18th: Harold - quit to save leshawna from elimination
17th: Beth - voted out
16th: Alejandro - voted out
15th: Owen - voted out

so here is where i would bring in the teams, and the reason i started merged is so the teams would be even because i wanted to do old people vs new people instead of heroes vs villains

so here are the teams

old vultures: lindsay, heather, leshawna, izzy, courtney, gwen, duncan
new hamsters: zoey, scott, dawn, mike, cameron, jo, lightning

okay so from here this is the elimination order:

14th: lightning - eliminated by jo who threw the challenge but used the chris head immunity thing so lightning got eliminated
13th - jo - voted out
12th - cameron - it was a race to the finish line and cameron was last
11th - mike - dawn used the immunity head to eliminate mije
10th - duncan - voted out
9th - gwen - eliminated by chris

MERGE

8th - courtney - voted out
7th: izzy - voted out

ok so then i had this idea to unmerge them into different teams so that the losing team would battle and someone would get eliminated

UNMERGE

new teams:
villainous vultures - scott and heather
average people (havent figured out the name yet lol) - leshawna, dawn
heroic hamsters - lindsay, zoey

6th - dawn - eliminated by tiebreaker with leshawna
5th - leshawna - lost the challenge and there was no one else on her team
4th - heather - she won the tiebreaker but scott used the immunity head thing
3rd - scott - he lost the challenge and there was no one on his team

okay so

MERGE

so this is the finale
lindsay vs zoey

so i decided the main winner is lindsay and the alternate is zoey, but because they're nice people in both endings they split the million with eachother so

1st/2nd - zoey
1st/2nd - lindsay

so this is the final order

18th - Harold
17th - Beth
16th - Alejandro
15th - Owen
14th - Lightning
13th - Jo
12th - Cameron
11th - Mike
10th - Duncan
9th - Gwen
8th - Courtney
7th - Izzy
6th - Dawn
5th - Leshawna
4th - Heather
3rd - Scott
1st/2nd - Zoey
1st/2nd - Lindsay

what do yall think?

Nice! I was pretty disappointed to find out Owen wasn't in All Stars when he's everyone's favorite. He won season 1, was in quite a lot of episodes in season 2 and 3 yet the creators decided he wasn't an all star. I would prefer Lindsay and Courtney as the All Stars finale by Lindsay and Zoey is fine.

I liked all of the finales except the Pahkitew Island one (well no one likes Pahkitew Island lol so makes sense). But they weren't all good.
Finales ranked in my opinion. Ridonculous Race not inluded.

1st - Season 3, World Tour: This was the best one, villain VS. villain the ultimate combination. It was so cool how Heather manipulated Alejandro and won. I watched that scene over a 100 times. Plus my profile aesthetics are from that episode I also loved it since it was in World Tour, my favorite season. The challenge was really interesting, very odd in my opinion.

2nd - Season 1, Island: Comes in second place! This was a classic since it was from when Total Drama first began and it featured likable characters, Owen + Gwen. I would've put this in first but this episode sort of helped ruin Trent's personallity. He was a cool character but after he got eliminated they really did him bad. Trent in Action is just… bleh, no one really likes him anymore and that's how it ends for Trent. But it was cool how they added the special after this episode.

3rd - Season 5, All Stars: *sigh* I can't believe I'm saying this but it was actually a good finale. I enjoyed it a lot. Mainly because 1) they fixed up Mike and Mal 2) The challenge. Without the finale Mike would end up like Trent and I liked the moats challenge. Adding the helpers was a good choice, but Heather and Alejandro were disgusting in that episode. And I think Lindsay and Courtney should've been finalists, but then again, it would ruin Mike. Plus I liked the sinking at the end lol

4th - Season 2, Action - I would put this in 3rd place since it's an OG season and pretty good but there is one huge thing that bugs me. The finalists were Beth and Duncan! The worst choice ever. Apparently I heard Lindsay was supposed to win but the voice actor was too busy. I would have loved to see Lindsay and Duncan battle.

5th - Season 4, Revenge of the Island - This would be 4th but Action was a classic season and you got to love that! Consider this tied with Action, finale was very good. But I would have liked to see Zoey and Cameron be finalists since I don't like Lightning that much.

6th - Season 5B, Pahkitew Island - Worst season. Of course it's at the bottom. I hate what they did to Dave, he was a good character in the first view episodes then they ruined him. And plus, Pahkitew Island ruined everything. We never found out about the Lindsay, Courtney, and Duncan love triangle or go to see what happened to the cast members that flew into space. And plus, the classic charaters that got ruined like Geoff, Bridgette, and Trent could've gotten fixed.

I don't understand how Total Dramarama is supposed to be related to the rest of Total Drama, if it's even supposed to be. The only thing that makes it similar to Total Drama is that it contains several characters from the series but as kids and also Chef who is the same age for some reason. They don't even show the original series anymore, just Total Dramarama.

Does Total Drama: The Ridonculous Race even count as part of the Total Drama series?

FrostyRAhAz wrote:

(well no one likes Pahkitew Island lol so makes sense)

I actually liked PI.

Honestly I don't know if there was a single character I liked from Pahkitew Island. Let me check.

EDIT: Probably Jasmine and Shawn would be the favorites, but I don't really remember how they acted. 2/14 isn't great.

I found the characters in PI fine. I think it was the plots that ruined it for me.

Za-Chary wrote:

Honestly I don't know if there was a single character I liked from Pahkitew Island. Let me check.

EDIT: Probably Jasmine and Shawn would be the favorites, but I don't really remember how they acted. 2/14 isn't great.

I also found the characters to not be likable. Jasmine and Shawn were the only good ones. But the episode where Scarlett turned out to be evil was a good twist, as well as Ella's elimination so I'll admit the eliminations in PI were pretty creative.

swiftrush wrote:

cheesyfriedeggs wrote:

FrostyRAhAz wrote:

(well no one likes Pahkitew Island lol so makes sense)

I actually liked PI.

I watched some of PI and then quit because it was just unbearable. From what I've heard about it though, I think it's better than All Stars.

It's actually not that bad I guess. I liked it, it's worth watching. But I didn't like the characters, that's what ruined it for me.

It's fine but I still like the original world tour eliminations the best.

Well, I think Sierra should have been in 4th place and eliminated for the same reason because she was a new character and we kinda just met her. Although the alliances you made were creative. And I think the episodes just wouldn't be the same with that order. Other than that it's good!

also i liked that chris is really really really really ugly thing ;)