Discuss Scratch

illusionist
Scratcher
48 posts

Block Colors

Custom blocks are a high-contrast purple color now.
Why are colors being tampered with at this stage in development? It just seems like a distraction to me…

In my opinion:

- the purple can confuse with looks blocks
- too-high contrast
- not a necessary change…I think brown worked nicely

Last edited by illusionist (Oct. 19, 2012 18:25:30)

Hardmath123
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

In an ideal world (i.e. BYOB ), clone is a reporter which reports a sprite object created. And clones can clone recursively. I think for the moment Scratch probably wouldn't want to add new complex data types, but how about the clone block reports the name of the sprite's clone (i.e. clone1, clone2, etc.)? Or a (most recent clone's name) reporter?
Lucario621
Scratcher
100+ posts

Block Colors

Yeah, the different colors do confuse me a bit. I'm not disliking it just for the sake of change, but the problem is that this makes all previous pictures, projects, and books made with screenshots of scripts completely outdated. That might seem like an unimportant issue since Scratch 2.0 is such a huge change, but this kind of change is the equivalent of changing a language's syntax! Sure, some minor changes of the tints of blocks (like to distinct between “Control” and Events“) is okay with me - but pen and data? Right now, there's a dark blue (motion), medium blue (sensing), light blue (pen), and a green-ish blue (pen)! Let's try to be practical here. I would probably be more satisfied if pen could simply get it's old color back, and data was light-blue instead.

Although I'll also agree with your description, ”eye-burning brighter". Some of the colors - particularly for pen, operators, and control, are a lot less appealing to me simply because it makes looking at scripts and reading their text a bit more difficult. Perhaps the colors aren't *that* much brighter, but considering the words aren't as clearly-defined as in Scratch 1.4 because of the different font, it's an issue to keep in mind. Just a subtle adjustment would be nice imo.

Last edited by Lucario621 (Oct. 1, 2012 18:52:28)

scimonster
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

Horrible colors. Like, seriously, why is pen bright blue?
Hardmath123
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

Yeah, we need darker colors. It makes the text more visible. Ideally we keep all the old colors except the colors for Events, which should be some form of orange like control, since they are in fact special control blocks. Also, while we're at it, it might be worth suggesting zebra coloring.
Lucario621
Scratcher
100+ posts

Block Colors

Hardmath123
Yeah, we need darker colors. It makes the text more visible. Ideally we keep all the old colors except the colors for Events, which should be some form of orange like control, since they are in fact special control blocks. Also, while we're at it, it might be worth suggesting zebra coloring.
Zebra coloring (from BYOB) would be a useful feature, but I think at this point with all of the new block colors, it would just be too confusing (mostly with the different shades of blue).
illusionist
Scratcher
48 posts

Block Colors

I don't like it. Its just another thing to throw me off my groove. The stage flip still bugs me…
scimonster
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

I am saved as of v155!
stevetheipad
Scratcher
500+ posts

Block Colors

The current colors are my favorite set so far…stick with 'em!

Lucario621
Scratcher
100+ posts

Block Colors

stevetheipad
The current colors are my favorite set so far…stick with 'em!

I agree!
silvershine
Scratcher
9 posts

Block Colors

Lucario621
stevetheipad
The current colors are my favorite set so far…stick with 'em!

I agree!
I'm happy with these as well. Perhaps I'm overanalyzing, but if I were being introduced to a new programming language, fun colors would be much more inviting than dull ones.
Lightnin
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

Awesome! Glad to hear that some of you are liking them.
jji7skyline
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

Lucario621
stevetheipad
The current colors are my favorite set so far…stick with 'em!

I agree!
I'm liking how images don't turn into links when quoted
illusionist
Scratcher
48 posts

Block Colors

Lightnin
Awesome! Glad to hear that some of you are liking them.

All of these posts were posted after you guys changed them back.
Lightnin
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

illusionist
Lightnin
Awesome! Glad to hear that some of you are liking them.

All of these posts were posted after you guys changed them back.

Yeah, I knew / know. Thanks for editing the first post.
illusionist
Scratcher
48 posts

Block Colors

The first post has been revised to reflect that this issue is not resolved anymore…
Hardmath123
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

Purple?! Come on, you can do better than that, ST!
Lightnin
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

Hardmath123
Purple?! Come on, you can do better than that, ST!

How / why can we do better than purple?
(Rather fond of it myself.)

scimonster
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

Now how do i tell the difference between 1.4 Looks and 2.0 Custom.
BoltBait
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Block Colors

I still don't like the fact that all the C-blocks are brown. Looks depressing.

I'd rather see them gold as they were before.

Powered by DjangoBB