Reported to be stickied

KingxDylan wrote:

Reported to be stickied

This has been reported to be stickied three times, and it did nothing.

Super_Scratch_Bros20 wrote:

KingxDylan wrote:

Reported to be stickied

This has been reported to be stickied three times, and it did nothing.

True. But I would really love to know what the Scratch Team actually thinks of this topic.

I would also like it if you added something about private messaging and collab accounts on here. Although they are in The Official List of Rejected Suggestions, I still see these kinds of suggestions popping up.

BUMP!

allwoodaj wrote:

I would also like it if you added something about private messaging and collab accounts on here. Although they are in The Official List of Rejected Suggestions, I still see these kinds of suggestions popping up.

I will think about it.

Shouldn't you mention the mass false reporting on here? It seems to be getting nonstop duplicates. Here's the oldest and most active one I can find.

Super_Scratch_Bros20 wrote:

Shouldn't you mention the mass false reporting on here? It seems to be getting nonstop duplicates. Here's the oldest and most active one I can find.

I think I agree with you but I will need my computer for that; so it will take some time.

Things that go BUMP in the night

Super_Scratch_Bros20 wrote:

Things that go BUMP in the night

Thanks. I had used them up.

R4356th wrote:

Super_Scratch_Bros20 wrote:

Shouldn't you mention the mass false reporting on here? It seems to be getting nonstop duplicates. Here's the oldest and most active one I can find.

I think I agree with you but I will need my computer for that; so it will take some time.

Got your computer yet?

Since you talked about only posting in English on this forum, perhaps you could add a link to the bottom of the discussion home with all the other languages (or at least mention it).

R4356th wrote:

-snip

• Can I suggest a rejected suggestion?
  Yes, you can suggest a rejected suggestion if you don't suggest exactly how it was suggested before, and make sure it does not go with what the Scratch Team mentioned as the reason for rejecting.
  

i'm pretty sure that if a suggestion is on the list of rejected suggestions, the ST isn't interested in adding it to scratch
edit: even if it's worded differently

64lu wrote:

R4356th wrote:

-snip

• Can I suggest a rejected suggestion?
  Yes, you can suggest a rejected suggestion if you don't suggest exactly how it was suggested before, and make sure it does not go with what the Scratch Team mentioned as the reason for rejecting.
  

i'm pretty sure that if a suggestion is on the list of rejected suggestions, the ST isn't interested in adding it to scratch
edit: even if it's worded differently

Not exactly. There's always a reason for it to be rejected, if you come up with a way to take that away, you can suggest it.

BearSlothCoding wrote:

64lu wrote:

R4356th wrote:

-snip

• Can I suggest a rejected suggestion?
  Yes, you can suggest a rejected suggestion if you don't suggest exactly how it was suggested before, and make sure it does not go with what the Scratch Team mentioned as the reason for rejecting.
  

i'm pretty sure that if a suggestion is on the list of rejected suggestions, the ST isn't interested in adding it to scratch
edit: even if it's worded differently

Not exactly. There's always a reason for it to be rejected, if you come up with a way to take that away, you can suggest it.

ok i just spent 15 minutes to find this quote, but:

Za-Chary wrote:

If a suggestion is “rejected,” that means that we are not interested in implementing it. Whether or not it used to exist is irrelevant.

from here

Super_Scratch_Bros20 wrote:

R4356th wrote:

Super_Scratch_Bros20 wrote:

Shouldn't you mention the mass false reporting on here? It seems to be getting nonstop duplicates. Here's the oldest and most active one I can find.

I think I agree with you but I will need my computer for that; so it will take some time.

Got your computer yet?

Whoops, sorry! I saw your post but did not have the time to respond to it. I will add it today (after about 7 hours).

• Does the Scratch Team actually implement suggestions?
  Of course! If they did not, there would be no point of having this category. Here is an example: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/3935333/ .
  

Not exactly. That wasn't exactly an implemented suggestion. I would consider it halfway.

Here's a list of implemented suggestions, though.

Also, in that same topic, Za-Chary* made this post. You may want to add to the first question what he notes on the eggplant emoji, and that the Suggestions Forums are not a ballot box. The suggestions may have upsides, but also many potential downsides that are risky for other users, no matter the supporter amount.

Super_Scratch_Bros20 wrote:

• Does the Scratch Team actually implement suggestions?
  Of course! If they did not, there would be no point of having this category. Here is an example: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/3935333/ .
  

Not exactly. That wasn't exactly an implemented suggestion. I would consider it halfway.

I do not think so as it was implemented in a way that made topic owner satisfied.

THIS IS A NINJA REPLY!