For those who don't know, Mr. Melon and Mr. Carrot are studios of people who remix featured projects and change them to involve either one of those. I think that this is disrespectful and kind of spamming.

This isn't really a question about Scratch, but i didn't know where to put it.

UniKittenGurl wrote:

For those who don't know, Mr. Melon and Mr. Carrot are studios of people who remix featured projects and change them to involve either one of those. I think that this is disrespectful and kind of spamming.

This isn't really a question about Scratch, but i didn't know where to put it.

I only actually use Scratch for the forums 90% of the time and when I'm not doing that I tend to avoid the explore section and home page, so I've never seen either of these. Based on your description though, this seems like it shouldn't be much of a problem

Auroura_Wolf wrote:

*snip

Based on your description though, this seems like it shouldn't be much of a problem

It's really not that much of a problem, but it's annoying and kind of rude to the makers of the original projects.

UniKittenGurl wrote:

Auroura_Wolf wrote:

*snip

Based on your description though, this seems like it shouldn't be much of a problem

It's really not that much of a problem, but it's annoying and kind of rude to the makers of the original projects.

They change the projects in a transformative way, why is it rude?

Fupicat wrote:

They change the projects in a transformative way, why is it rude?

I guess it's that if you spend a lot of time on something for someone to basically just reskin it for a funny joke you'd probably be a bit annoyed, but it's not particularly a problem or anything that breaks the guidelines.

TheRealNetherBefore wrote:

Fupicat wrote:

They change the projects in a transformative way, why is it rude?

I guess it's that if you spend a lot of time on something for someone to basically just reskin it for a funny joke you'd probably be a bit annoyed, but it's not particularly a problem or anything that breaks the guidelines.

Yeah, I personally would not feel offended by it, but if it offends anyone, it still doesn't break Community Guidelines, which states that a remix with any kind of visible change, no matter how small, is valid.

You may talk to https://scratch.mit.edu/users/unknownscratcher1234/