Deserves a bump

Hm… I need a very formal template for this. One second, please.
*goes to Office Depot to buy posterboard*

Positive Effects

• Helps direct New Scratchers to the stickies
  

Negative Effects

• The mockups use ugly colors that would make a lot of forum users stop visiting. They also irritate my eyes.
  
• Clutters up the page
  
• Seems a little overkill and would probably cause more problems than it would solve
  
• Practically forces users to click the stickies, even if they've already been read
  

THE VERDICT:
drum roll pls

10% support. I don't think it would be necessary.

jokebookservice1 wrote:

Littledoggygirl45 wrote:

Support

Hello

Please don't quote someone else without adding your own opinions to the discussion.

I don't like the idea of changing the text/background color; maybe just add a border-left to each topic row thing and color-code that one (so that the text continues to be legible)?

Sheep_maker wrote:

I don't like the idea of changing the text/background color; maybe just add a border-left to each topic row thing and color-code that one (so that the text continues to be legible)?

Hmm, that's a good idea.

The4thPixel wrote:

Negative Effects

• The mockups use ugly colors that would make a lot of forum users stop visiting. They also irritate my eyes. The mockup colors are a rough draft.
  
• Clutters up the page How so? It just adds color.
  
• Seems a little overkill and would probably cause more problems than it would solve Hmm, maybe.
  
• Practically forces users to click the stickies, even if they've already been read If they are read, it would probably be slightly darker.
  

The4thPixel wrote:

Hm… I need a very formal template for this. One second, please.
*goes to Office Depot to buy posterboard*

Positive Effects

• Helps direct New Scratchers to the stickies
  

Negative Effects

• The mockups use ugly colors that would make a lot of forum users stop visiting. They also irritate my eyes.
  
• Clutters up the page
  
• Seems a little overkill and would probably cause more problems than it would solve
  
• Practically forces users to click the stickies, even if they've already been read
  

THE VERDICT:
drum roll pls

10% support. I don't think it would be necessary.

jokebookservice1 wrote:

Littledoggygirl45 wrote:

Support

Hello

Please don't quote someone else without adding your own opinions to the discussion.

Lol yeah, thanks! I did add some stuff on page 2 though, not that it matters

Scratcher1002 wrote:

bump

Please don't necropost (It is your own, but it has been dead for uh, 2 years)

TheAdriCoolManDude wrote:

Scratcher1002 wrote:

bump

Please don't necropost (It is your own, but it has been dead for uh, 2 years)

You can't necropost is suggetions, unless the topic isn't relevent.
—
OP, support- this would keep things organised.
Plus, it would be nice to have a “Color code” box or something, saying “Red = Unread” and “Yellow = Followed topic”, or something like that.

PrincessFlowerTV wrote:

Plus, it would be nice to have a “Color code” box or something, saying “Red = Unread” and “Yellow = Followed topic”, or something like that.

^ Support for this, if that wasn't added then this would happen:

A Scratcher wrote:

What does the purple highlighted topic mean? I'm confused!

on one hand, this could be very nice and useful. on the other, it could just create clutter and it might not work with scratch's already existing forum system. either way, i don't take any stance on this suggestion.