I know the concept of Scratch project reviews has been done like a million times before, but just here me out before flagging me as a duplicate. There are a lot of Scratch project reviewers, but not that many of them go really in-depth into why they like or dislike a project & just end up being vague & not helpful at all. So that's where I come in, I'm going to actually make an in-depth analysis complete with constructive criticism about what I think of YOUR projects. Also, another thing to set me apart from the rest, my reviews will actually be in video format & will be scripted, so I won't just play it for 10 minutes, address what's happening on the screen & not say what I think of it at all. So go ahead, I want you to request your projects for me to review & I'll say what I do like about it, what I don't like about it, & my overall thoughts on it, but first some quick rules for suggesting projects:

1. I won't hold back on criticism, so if you want me to review your game but you're too scared I'll give it a bad review, make it better. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED
2. I'll only accept games, I won't review animations, art or other things that don't have goals or objectives
3. If your game is hard to understand, provide instructions so I don't get confused
4. I'll rate your games on a scale of 0 to 20 (or 0-10 in halves), don't use this as competition with other scratchers
5. This is meant to be taken into account for when your making future games, don't feel discouraged if your game gets a bad review
And that's just about it!
Please follow these rules & if you do, this thread shouldn't get pulled down by the Scratch Team.
I look forward to everything I'll be able to review.

Sincerely
~Bailz_Gamer

OS Gaming Console Please!

+It's all complete except City Cast, but there's so much other stuff to do you probably don't need to review that game anyway! I'd like your thoughts on it though, except I hope that it doesn't affect the score as I want the other two available games to bring up the score.

Since I'm not really busy on making games any more I think I'll revive this topic.
Sorry I wasn't active at all before but I was just busy with my regular reviews (my YT name is BlazeNitromian234). I'll also be making a few changes so I can get these out faster.
1) Reviews will be in the form of scratch projects
2) The rating system will only be from 1-10

So yes, I'm going to start doing this again. Hopefully it goes better this time.

Sounds interesting, I may have to see what I'd like to be reviewed.

bump

I'd appreciate having this reviewed please!

Hi!
This is my first project and I'm looking for some constructive criticism for it. Could you review my game? Thanks!
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/16778249/#player

Thanks for the requests. The reviews should be up soon (they'll be on the account “BailzReviews”).

Sonicfan12p's review: http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/20049191/
Jessyb16's review: (accidentally deleted)

bump

Are you still doing this? If so, please review my newest game Doodle Adventure, I'd like some feedback.

Hi! I really should stop making projects and start finishing some, because I really like the idea of your reviewer! I'm gonna post here again once I've either finished MyCity or Doors.

coolgem923's review: http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/20302862/

I also accidentally deleted the Hole in One review. I thought if I changed the name, it would count it as a different project. I officially hate Scratch 2.0.

I'm sorry that your review of my game got deleted; it was really helpful, and I agreed with almost everything you said. If you're thinking about re-doing it, I've fixed some of the problems and added a few things, so a new review would be appreciated!

Could you please review this project?
https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/68636968/
It would be very much appreciated.

Can you review my game, Felix Tales? https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/47595518/

EDIT; Well, I now realise that this post is a year old, so this comment was basicly irrelevant. Can't delete this post, though…