Get rid of blocking "First Person" in the search results

Lu2333

aking_ wrote:
sorry Charles I stole your idea

New Page Post!

Last edited by Lu2333 (Nov. 2, 2017 18:07:26)

YubNubEwok

Lu2333 wrote:

New Page Post!

If you're going to say something, make sure it adds to the topic (e.g- saying support/no support/semi-support and providing reasons why.)

Last edited by YubNubEwok (Nov. 2, 2017 20:28:03)

aking_

YubNubEwok wrote:
If you're going to say something, make sure it adds to the topic (e.g- saying support/no support/semi-support and providing reasons why.)

Me? Or Lu?

YubNubEwok

aking_ wrote:
YubNubEwok wrote:
If you're going to say something, make sure it adds to the topic (e.g- saying support/no support/semi-support and providing reasons why.)
Me? Or Lu?

Lu, I'll edit my post to make it clear I was replying to Lu.

aking_

YubNubEwok wrote:
Lu, I'll edit my post to make it clear I was replying to Lu.

My bad lol

YubNubEwok

aking_ wrote:
YubNubEwok wrote:
Lu, I'll edit my post to make it clear I was replying to Lu.
My bad lol

It's okay.

Cub56

Bump

Cub56

Bump

blue-circle

Support. Like seriously scratch, somebody could make a racing game or something like that and not have anyone see there hard work because it has 2 words. Plus, an FPS is fine as long as there is no blood and people don't like fall on the floor and die or something. This website is not just for 4 year olds!

M1mikyu

Or, first person could refer to the writing style. You should add that to examples of stuff that could be blocked

goldfish678

i completely agree–if they're letting people upload that (not to mention completely appropriate) stuff to the website, then they shouldn't be filtering it out from search results… also if it's nfe it's not going to show up in the first place.

M1mikyu

Aqua-sempai wrote:
No support, as per what Randomperson1791 apparently said according to other people's quotes.

Randomperson1791 wrote:
No support.
First person projects involve 3D, which might confuse new scratchers.

What kind of reason is THAT? Just because it can be confusing doesn’t mean you can ban it altogether

Cub56

Aqua-sempai wrote:
No support, as per what Randomperson1791 apparently said according to other people's quotes.

Randomperson1791 wrote:
No support.
First person projects involve 3D, which might confuse new scratchers.

Why would it be confusing? They're not programming it themselves, they're just playing the game. They probably play other 3D games outside of Scratch.

Also by this logic you may as well block viewing every complex project on Scratch so it won't be “confusing” - this wouldn't be a reason to block anything.

Not blocking this would also show new Scratchers that 3D can be done in Scratch.

blue-circle

M1mikyu wrote:
Aqua-sempai wrote:
No support, as per what Randomperson1791 apparently said according to other people's quotes.

Randomperson1791 wrote:
No support.
First person projects involve 3D, which might confuse new scratchers.
What kind of reason is THAT? Just because it can be confusing doesn’t mean you can ban it altogether

Thats literally the weirdest and most pointless reason ever! Thats like saying a toddler can't go to school because he will be confused.

YubNubEwok

blue-circle wrote:
M1mikyu wrote:
Aqua-sempai wrote:
No support, as per what Randomperson1791 apparently said according to other people's quotes.

Randomperson1791 wrote:
No support.
First person projects involve 3D, which might confuse new scratchers.
What kind of reason is THAT? Just because it can be confusing doesn’t mean you can ban it altogether
Thats literally the weirdest and most pointless reason ever! Thats like saying a toddler can't go to school because he will be confused.

Exactly! We go to school to learn, why can't you go to a certain game to learn?

YubNubEwok

Aqua-sempai wrote:
blue-circle wrote:
M1mikyu wrote:
Aqua-sempai wrote:
No support, as per what Randomperson1791 apparently said according to other people's quotes.

Randomperson1791 wrote:
No support.
First person projects involve 3D, which might confuse new scratchers.
What kind of reason is THAT? Just because it can be confusing doesn’t mean you can ban it altogether
Thats literally the weirdest and most pointless reason ever! Thats like saying a toddler can't go to school because he will be confused.
A toddler shouldn't go to school, it's too young to force studies on a child at that age.

That's not relevant to the conversation. No matter what age the child is, blue-circle is just trying to prove his point.

goldfish678

Randomperson1791 wrote:
No support.
First person projects involve 3D, which might confuse new scratchers.

okay, but you're not just going to censor something out from search results because it's, quote, “confusing for new scratchers”. it doesn't really matter because they're the ones that looked up that in the first place, and if they're confused, they have options. they can leave a comment asking how it works. they can come back to it after building up experience. or they can just enjoy the project for what it is. or if they're looking to get some value out of a project rather than just looking at it, they can find other, simpler projects that a. they can understand and b. they would benefit from as far as experience. so in my opinion, that's not a reason to filter out projects at all.

Last edited by goldfish678 (Jan. 11, 2018 16:02:36)

Cub56

goldfish678 wrote:
Randomperson1791 wrote:
No support.
First person projects involve 3D, which might confuse new scratchers.
okay, but you're not just going to censor something out from search results because it's, quote, “confusing for new scratchers”. it doesn't really matter because they're the ones that looked up that in the first place, and if they're confused, they have options. they can leave a comment asking how it works. they can come back to it after building up experience. or they can just enjoy the project for what it is. or if they're looking to get some value out of a project rather than just looking at it, they can find other, simpler projects that a. they can understand and b. they would benefit from as far as experience. so in my opinion, that's not a reason to filter out projects at all.

That's true, playing Minecraft doesn't confuse people who are new to programming even if they don't know how it works

GEODASH69

Support. Not all FPS games are inappropriate.

MathlyCat

You have rights on the internet????

I find a lot of this poor filtering/quick judgement stuff a little redundant by the ST, they can't actually be doing this fast enough to not realize this many flaws?

It isn't as bad as Roblox at least. Try to censor everything, never works though

Discuss Scratch