LIST OF REJECTED SUGGESTIONS (READ BEFORE SUGGESTING ANYTHING)

DaEpikDude

ScratchCatHELLO wrote:
What’s a “Custom reporter”?

It's like a custom block (you know, the purple ones) but it's one of the rounded blocks that reports something.
That is…

custom stack block::custom

(custom reporter::custom)

set [variable v] to ((variable) to power of (2)::custom)//Example of how they might be used

-ShadowOfTheFuture-

Lu2333 wrote:
Missingno50 wrote:
Why FNAF to be banned out of all things, and not the rest of the horror genre?
FNAF Left Scratch Banned In Many Schools, And Some Parents Said Their Kid Had Nightmares. Basically, FNAF Projects Left Scratch With A Damaged Reputation.
Also It's Not Banned, Just NFE.

FNAF isn't really outright banned, it's just the inappropriate projects (like projects with jumpscares) that are.

DaEpikDude

-ShadowOfTheFuture- wrote:
Lu2333 wrote:
Missingno50 wrote:
Why FNAF to be banned out of all things, and not the rest of the horror genre?
FNAF Left Scratch Banned In Many Schools, And Some Parents Said Their Kid Had Nightmares. Basically, FNAF Projects Left Scratch With A Damaged Reputation.
Also It's Not Banned, Just NFE.

FNAF isn't really outright banned, it's just the inappropriate projects (like projects with jumpscares) that are.

Which happens to be most FNAF projects, that's all.
Episode 60: The Rule Awakens

GizzyGazzy360

So as it is many people do want to use scratch blocks in a 3d engine https://wiki.scratch.mit.edu/wiki/BeetleBlocks go there this is based off of scratch and is awesome for 3d games

DaEpikDude

GizzyGazzy360 wrote:
-snip-

Uh, how is that related to rejected suggestions?

3D scratch is already there, if that's what you're saying.

red_king_cyclops

12. A 13+ version of the website

Scratch is designed for all ages, and dividing the community would not really help anybody.

If people want to make projects inappropriate for children on this website then they should instead use a real coding language. That way they can do anything they want.

Edit: changed the real to real

Last edited by red_king_cyclops (Oct. 28, 2017 12:34:32)

DaEpikDude

red_king_cyclops wrote:
12. A 13+ version of the website

Scratch is designed for all ages, and dividing the community would not really help anybody.

If people want to make projects inappropriate for children on this website then they should instead use a real coding language. That way they can do anything they want.

Not sure if I like the use of the word “real” highlighted with text effects. I get that Scratch isn't a “real” language per se, but it's still a programming language (just a very easy to use one).

red_king_cyclops

DaEpikDude wrote:
red_king_cyclops wrote:
12. A 13+ version of the website

Scratch is designed for all ages, and dividing the community would not really help anybody.

If people want to make projects inappropriate for children on this website then they should instead use a real coding language. That way they can do anything they want.
Not sure if I like the use of the word “real” highlighted with text effects. I get that Scratch isn't a “real” language per se, but it's still a programming language (just a very easy to use one).

Fare enough.

SPEEDISKey139

Lu2333 wrote:
Missingno50 wrote:
Why FNAF to be banned out of all things, and not the rest of the horror genre?
FNAF Left Scratch Banned In Many Schools, And Some Parents Said Their Kid Had Nightmares. Basically, FNAF Projects Left Scratch With A Damaged Reputation.
Also It's Not Banned, Just NFE.

Is this from a reliable news source?

FancyFoxy

SPEEDISKey139 wrote:
Lu2333 wrote:
Missingno50 wrote:
Why FNAF to be banned out of all things, and not the rest of the horror genre?
FNAF Left Scratch Banned In Many Schools, And Some Parents Said Their Kid Had Nightmares. Basically, FNAF Projects Left Scratch With A Damaged Reputation.
Also It's Not Banned, Just NFE.
Is this from a reliable news source?

Yes, the Scratch Team announced it.

Charles12310

Add “Server blocks”. It shows ambiguity.

fphiladelphia

Charles12310 wrote:
Add “Server blocks”. It shows ambiguity.

Wait, didn’t you say no suggestions below this line?

DaEpikDude

fphiladelphia wrote:
Charles12310 wrote:
Add “Server blocks”. It shows ambiguity.
Wait, didn’t you say no suggestions below this line?

No, he's saying that server blocks should be added to the list of rejected suggestions, not to Scratch.

slimer9k

jeezus you tyep a BUNCH

ask [this guy tyeped a BUNCH] and wait

CODDERJXY

I want to explain that changing your username would be hard since unlike youtube where the link to a channel is a random code like uehbGD76hjkl it is your username, also people can make their username be griffpatch or other famous scratcher and copy or remix all of his or her project and trick people even if you can't change your username to a username that is a already taken and as it says above it would make it harder for the scratch team to moderate.

PJFAUST

What are Custom Reporters?

DaEpikDude

PJFAUST wrote:
What are Custom Reporters?

A reporter is one of the rounded blocks that fits into string / number inputs. For example:

(direction)
(timer)
(variable)
([abs v] of (-13)::operators)

Custom reporters are a suggestion to make custom blocks that return a value. For example:

define ((number::custom) to power of (number2::custom))
set [out v] to [1]
repeat (number2::custom)
set [out v] to ((out) * (number::custom))
end
report (out)::custom//wanted to make this a cap but couldn't figure it out

Then you can use that custom block to instantly report something.

Charles12310

Charles12310 wrote:
————————–THIS IS A LINE (YOU DON'T SAY?)————————–
Users cannot suggest features beneath this line. There is a reason why this forum exists, where you can suggest anything. This topic is just one of the topics. The user didn't say you can suggest stuff here. If this doesn't go successful, then this topic may be report to be closed.

fphiladelphia wrote:
Charles12310 wrote:
Add “Server blocks”. It shows ambiguity.
Wait, didn’t you say no suggestions below this line?

I was requesting to make a suggestion rejected, not to add the feature to the site.

Last edited by Charles12310 (Nov. 3, 2017 02:06:14)

EclipsedGames

I think the username changes are doable; assigning each unique profile a “user ID” which remains static allows the ST to moderate easily, and Scratchers don't have to create new accounts just to change username.

paws48

I-Iz-A-Litten wrote:
IlanaLeigh8 wrote:
paws48 wrote:
IlanaLeigh8 wrote:
I personally think Scratch should ban FNAF. Scratch is a community open to all ages. Before you start saying “But kids who'll get scared should use Scratch Jr.!” Listen to this:
A 7-year-old who does not know about Scratch JR could be on scratch, casually browsing projects, suddenly to see something that could haunt their dreams forever. Any aged person could be looking at these, so we should keep this community open to all ages, as it's supposed to be. Scratch is for sharing fun codes to inspire, not to scare. We should help make this community a better and more flexible place.
If you have an opposing opinion, feel free to reply. If you share my opinion, please reply as well. I'm curious to see how many people support and do not support this matter.
Of course, no offense intended to those who want FNAF to stay.
I think that they really should. So we can't post projects that are too scary, but FNAF is still allowed? I don't think we should fully ban FNAF. I only think that we as a community should be stricter on what applies to being too scary. Furthermore, I think that a simple ban of jumpscares our screenshots from the game should be good in my opinion. If projects are too scary for some ages, it doesn't belong on Scratch. And about going to Scratch JR, Scratch JR is unadvanced even for my little sister. She joined regular Scratch instead. @Stitchy-Glitchy. Scratch JR is almost impossible to make anything decent with. Scratch is generally for kids 8+, but should still be appropriate for a slightly younger audience. What we should really be thinking about banning is mentioning anything about adult TV shows such as Rick and Morty and Family Guy. Kids will look up these shows and watch them on sites such as Youtube although them being innapropriate for their age.
That is a very good point! Especially with the adult shows content.

I also think they should ban the topic of games such as Yandre Simulator, I haven't played it, but I heard the plot is crazy gruesome.

Agreed.

Discuss Scratch