duckboycool wrote:

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

I support this for reasons I already said.

WolfCat67 wrote:

duckboycool wrote:

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

I support this for reasons I already said.

I support this instead of what was said earlier, as it's really something we need. After all, it's really difficult for normal users to point out things we should change on the wiki without applying to get their own account. I don't think “Join the Wiki” is really needed; because there could be a sticky for that. The hidden Admin and EW forum is useful as well, I bet.

customhacker wrote:

WolfCat67 wrote:

duckboycool wrote:

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

I support this for reasons I already said.

I support this instead of what was said earlier, as it's really something we need. After all, it's really difficult for normal users to point out things we should change on the wiki without applying to get their own account. I don't think “Join the Wiki” is really needed; because there could be a sticky for that. The hidden Admin and EW forum is useful as well, I bet.

Agreed. However I think users may want to know how to join, what form to fill out, etc.?

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

bigpuppy wrote:

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

This. As I said before, there's really no need for a private forum for regular wiki users, but this could allow private forums for EWs/Admins without them having to use external programs.

MClovers wrote:

bigpuppy wrote:

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

This. As I said before, there's really no need for a private forum for regular wiki users, but this could allow private forums for EWs/Admins without them having to use external programs.

I'd say that would be fine and the regular wikians can use the CP

bigpuppy wrote:

MClovers wrote:

bigpuppy wrote:

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

This. As I said before, there's really no need for a private forum for regular wiki users, but this could allow private forums for EWs/Admins without them having to use external programs.

I'd say that would be fine and the regular wikians can use the CP

Yes. Plus it'd add a forum for regular users to ask questions about the wiki

MClovers wrote:

bigpuppy wrote:

MClovers wrote:

bigpuppy wrote:

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

This. As I said before, there's really no need for a private forum for regular wiki users, but this could allow private forums for EWs/Admins without them having to use external programs.

I'd say that would be fine and the regular wikians can use the CP

Yes. Plus it'd add a forum for regular users to ask questions about the wiki

Do you mean regular wikians or non-wikians?

WolfCat67 wrote:

MClovers wrote:

bigpuppy wrote:

MClovers wrote:

bigpuppy wrote:

customhacker wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

This. As I said before, there's really no need for a private forum for regular wiki users, but this could allow private forums for EWs/Admins without them having to use external programs.

I'd say that would be fine and the regular wikians can use the CP

Yes. Plus it'd add a forum for regular users to ask questions about the wiki

Do you mean regular wikians or non-wikians?

Any old user, like non-wikians, to talk about the wiki as there is currently no place to do so (?).

WolfCat67 wrote:

-snip-
Any old user, like non-wikians, to talk about the wiki as there is currently no place to do so (?).

kenny2scratch wrote:

1. Consider technical restrictions - is it worth it to set up a cross-site system to make sure users are in the Wiki?
2. There have been plenty of bureaucrat messages disliking the exclusivity of the wiki - it’s already bad enough that only wikians can edit, how do you think people would feel if we showed this sub forum to their face and told them they can’t post in it?
3. The only reason the moderator forums are private is because some of the content there is potentially sensitive/libelous - not so with the wiki - I disagree with making the wiki forums private to view.

In general, I don’t really like this idea, sorry.

also can someone teach me how to use BBcode numbered lists thanks

[list=Start#]
[*] Item 1
[*] Item 2
[*] Item 3
[/list]

customhacker wrote: wrote:

Visible to the Community:
The Scratch Wiki - Suggest articles, point out errors, or ask for basic wiki information
Join the Wiki - Get help with your application, find all your resources

Hidden from the Community:
Experienced Wikian and Admin Forum

kenny2scratch wrote:

I saw that compromise - I’m saying restricting posting to wiki editors is technically challenging (kinda) and worse than not being able to edit.

myloganator1 wrote:

I think this could be useful.

set [post v] to [deleted]

MClovers wrote:

myloganator1 wrote:

I think this could be useful.

Please explain why you think so