Merge the two "my stuff" buttons.

yzyzyz

so recently I talked with @fancyfoxy about the fact that for no reason, there are TWO SEPARATE “my stuff” buttons on the main menu.
I think this double button is unnecessary, and you only need to have just one.
please suggest which one of them should be removed
supporters: 6
drop down:3 sidebar:3 whichever:0
this time, I will not create a giant studio. This is a smaller problem than bringing back the discuss tab.
keep scratching! @yzyzyz

Last edited by yzyzyz (July 12, 2017 10:39:08)

FancyFoxy

Support! I think we should just get rid of the My Stuff button in the drop-down menu, because the extra click.

Auroura_Wolf

Aha, you made it! So, yeah, like I said on the other topic, I would support this, and personally I would remove the one on the bar, not in the drop down menu
EDIT: my reasoning is just that it slightly shortens the bar, it's more clear what it does (it actually says it, instead of being a symbol) and I'm personally accustomed to using the drop down one

Last edited by Auroura_Wolf (July 9, 2017 15:01:08)

yzyzyz

messy quotes…

Last edited by yzyzyz (July 9, 2017 15:00:59)

duckboycool

What's the point of removing the one in the dropdown?

No support, I think that the button should stay there, and it's not causing any problems in the dropdown.

powercon5

There is no need for both. I would remove the one at the top. It would add more space.

FancyFoxy

duckboycool wrote:
What's the point of removing the one in the dropdown?

No support, I think that the button should stay there, and it's not causing any problems in the dropdown.

But is the repitition really necessary? I mean, Scratch removed the discuss button, which made many angry(though not me), but they have two of the same button.

duckboycool

It may not be necessary, but a common forum motto states, “If it ain't broke, don't fix it.”

walkcycle

Don't really see the problem. No support.

Smurphy13AWESOME

I think it's there so New Scratchers can be more likely to find it…

I don't know though. It doesn't bother me, why, and why not?

yzyzyz

walkcycle wrote:
Don't really see the problem. No support.

this is more a problem of confusion then anything else.

DisasterPug

I would remove the file button IDK why but I just like clicking the dropdown

walkcycle

never have i ever found it confusing

yzyzyz

bump

DownsGameClub

yzyzyz wrote:
walkcycle wrote:
Don't really see the problem. No support.
this is more a problem of confusion then anything else.

confusion?
Why would me going to the exact same place using almost the exact same buttons cause confusion? Could you elaborate?

yzyzyz

DownsGameClub wrote:
yzyzyz wrote:
walkcycle wrote:
Don't really see the problem. No support.
this is more a problem of confusion then anything else.
confusion?
Why would me going to the exact same place using almost the exact same buttons cause confusion? Could you elaborate?

it more of a confusion about why there are two buttons.

DownsGameClub

yzyzyz wrote:
DownsGameClub wrote:
yzyzyz wrote:
walkcycle wrote:
Don't really see the problem. No support.
this is more a problem of confusion then anything else.
confusion?
Why would me going to the exact same place using almost the exact same buttons cause confusion? Could you elaborate?
it more of a confusion about why there are two buttons.

That really shouldn't be a long term focus of Scratch.

TheOrneryOpossum

Support! I occasionally will check on my profile and then see the other My Stuff button and think, Why does that need to be there? I think that the drop-down one should be removed. Although, this is just a annoying little problem. If Scratch kept it, it wouldn't be so bad. I do see the wisdom in taking it away also.

MathlyCat

yzyzyz wrote:
DownsGameClub wrote:
yzyzyz wrote:
walkcycle wrote:
Don't really see the problem. No support.
this is more a problem of confusion then anything else.
confusion?
Why would me going to the exact same place using almost the exact same buttons cause confusion? Could you elaborate?
it more of a confusion about why there are two buttons.

What confusion?
I don't understand. Just come to accept there are two?

-1

LionHeart70

duckboycool wrote:
What's the point of removing the one in the dropdown?

No support, I think that the button should stay there, and it's not causing any problems in the dropdown.

I don't see much of a reason for removing it either, and I'm used to seeing it in the dropdown menu (even though I never click it).. so it might bother a few users.. so.. I don't have much support either.

Discuss Scratch