Discuss Scratch
- monstermash3
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
You know the new “thanks to” credit system for remixes?
Sometimes there are long remix chains, like remix collaborations, where the creator of the original project participates later. (For example, User 1 starts the collab, User 2 remixes it, then User 1 remixes User 2's remix…)
So, let's say User 1 makes part 1, then User 2 remixes adding a part 2, then User 1 remixes adding a part 3. With the new system, this is what the Notes and Credits on part 3 would say:
Thanks to User 2 for:
part 2 (Project Remixed)
Thanks to User 1 for:
part 1 (Original Project)
But then the title would say, “part 3 by User 1”. So it basically looks like User 1 is thanking himself or herself.
So maybe if someone's project is in a remix chain where the original project was created by that same user, it would say, “I created the original project: (project name)” instead of “Thanks to (creator's username) for: (project name) (Original Project)”.
Sometimes there are long remix chains, like remix collaborations, where the creator of the original project participates later. (For example, User 1 starts the collab, User 2 remixes it, then User 1 remixes User 2's remix…)
So, let's say User 1 makes part 1, then User 2 remixes adding a part 2, then User 1 remixes adding a part 3. With the new system, this is what the Notes and Credits on part 3 would say:
Thanks to User 2 for:
part 2 (Project Remixed)
Thanks to User 1 for:
part 1 (Original Project)
But then the title would say, “part 3 by User 1”. So it basically looks like User 1 is thanking himself or herself.
So maybe if someone's project is in a remix chain where the original project was created by that same user, it would say, “I created the original project: (project name)” instead of “Thanks to (creator's username) for: (project name) (Original Project)”.
Last edited by monstermash3 (July 7, 2017 22:54:18)
(Swallowed by an evil kumquat who was just taking a walk in the neighborhood of evil kumquats when they saw a garage sale where they bought a plate which they used to eat but they discovered that it leaked and they went to get their money back but the sale was over so they went in the house but the door was locked so they got their key but it didn't fit so they went home to use the key on the right door which was their own door and then they decided to swallow a signature for no reason.)
- Digital_Gaming
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
Support.
If you want to join the most creative studio on Scratch than ask to join Scratch Underground If you want to join Scratches Premium studio than ask to join Scratch Deluxe I hope you ask to join one of those and have a nice day. Check out my Official fan club!Click here if you want to check out my amazing projects DIGITAL GAMING SCRATCH AWARDS 2017
CHECK OUT THE OFFCIAL TOPICS FOR FORZA, HALO , CALL OF DUTY, BATTLEFEILD 1,THE CREW,DESTINY, RESIDENT EVIL,SONIC BOOM, PIXAR AND SUPER MARIO RUN
SCRATCH SUPERGUIDE
OFFICIAL TOPIC FOR TALKING ABOUT SHIPS
- Lythium
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
Thank you.It is qutie obvious, like the OP states, it is weird to remix your own project, and the credit giver doesn't say that you actually owned the original.Support.Why?
- MathlyCat
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
Cool idea, it probably is fairly contradictory to credit yourself in remixes
Think before you act.
Actions speek louder than words.
hi there fella
Actions speek louder than words.
hi there fella
- orangeshortstuff
- Scratcher
32 posts
The new remix system
Seems a better fit in Bugs and Gliches, but support.
- iolanthus
- New Scratcher
93 posts
The new remix system
yeah, exactly LOL Cool idea, it probably is fairly contradictory to credit yourself in remixes
support <3
switch on the sky, watch the stars glow for you
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
- jokebookservice1
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
Why Support.
But the suggestions forum isn't really a place to vote on the OP. If you don't have any new ideas, then technically you shouldn't post (lots of people make this mistake, don't worry). So in a perfect Suggestions forum, a perfect suggestion should have no responses (just bumps, and the Scratch Team saying they accepted/rejected it at the very end)It is qutie obvious, like the OP states, it is weird to remix your own project, and the credit giver doesn't say that you actually owned the original.Support.Why?
- monstermash3
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
This isn't exactly a bug, it's probably just something that hasn't been considered yet. Seems a better fit in Bugs and Gliches, but support.
There's probably no such thing as a perfect suggestion… So in a perfect Suggestions forum, a perfect suggestion should have no responses (just bumps, and the Scratch Team saying they accepted/rejected it at the very end)
Support.
Support.
Cool idea, it probably is fairly contradictory to credit yourself in remixes
Seems a better fit in Bugs and Gliches, but support.
Thanks!yeah, exactly LOL Cool idea, it probably is fairly contradictory to credit yourself in remixes
support <3
Last edited by monstermash3 (Oct. 12, 2016 23:31:37)
(Swallowed by an evil kumquat who was just taking a walk in the neighborhood of evil kumquats when they saw a garage sale where they bought a plate which they used to eat but they discovered that it leaked and they went to get their money back but the sale was over so they went in the house but the door was locked so they got their key but it didn't fit so they went home to use the key on the right door which was their own door and then they decided to swallow a signature for no reason.)
- ateesdalejr
- Scratcher
100+ posts
The new remix system
Totally support this suggestion as it lessens confusion that may be caused by that text!
Last edited by ateesdalejr (Oct. 15, 2016 00:26:52)
…
- monstermash3
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
I'm talking about how it now says “thanks”, not the links. I really like the way the remix system works now Due to the fact I use it for versioning changes. Where I remix my previous version with my newer version. And if something is wrong I can work on the remix in peace. And when I have the remix shared. I can see a link to the previous version.
(Swallowed by an evil kumquat who was just taking a walk in the neighborhood of evil kumquats when they saw a garage sale where they bought a plate which they used to eat but they discovered that it leaked and they went to get their money back but the sale was over so they went in the house but the door was locked so they got their key but it didn't fit so they went home to use the key on the right door which was their own door and then they decided to swallow a signature for no reason.)
- ateesdalejr
- Scratcher
100+ posts
The new remix system
Ah I get it. I'll edit my original post to support!I'm talking about how it now says “thanks”, not the links. I really like the way the remix system works now Due to the fact I use it for versioning changes. Where I remix my previous version with my newer version. And if something is wrong I can work on the remix in peace. And when I have the remix shared. I can see a link to the previous version.
…
- monstermash3
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
Ok, thanks!Ah I get it. I'll edit my original post to support!I'm talking about how it now says “thanks”, not the links. I really like the way the remix system works now Due to the fact I use it for versioning changes. Where I remix my previous version with my newer version. And if something is wrong I can work on the remix in peace. And when I have the remix shared. I can see a link to the previous version.
(Swallowed by an evil kumquat who was just taking a walk in the neighborhood of evil kumquats when they saw a garage sale where they bought a plate which they used to eat but they discovered that it leaked and they went to get their money back but the sale was over so they went in the house but the door was locked so they got their key but it didn't fit so they went home to use the key on the right door which was their own door and then they decided to swallow a signature for no reason.)
- monstermash3
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
Bump.
(Swallowed by an evil kumquat who was just taking a walk in the neighborhood of evil kumquats when they saw a garage sale where they bought a plate which they used to eat but they discovered that it leaked and they went to get their money back but the sale was over so they went in the house but the door was locked so they got their key but it didn't fit so they went home to use the key on the right door which was their own door and then they decided to swallow a signature for no reason.)
- Scratcher1002
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
Hmm, my problem with this is that, it's not very weird to credit yourself if you contributed.
Support though. Nope, no reason, just support. Couldn't really find much of a reason.
Support though. Nope, no reason, just support. Couldn't really find much of a reason.
Nothing is or probably will be perfect. Plus, the “voting” is feedback, without feedback, and rebuttals, and new ideas, additions, etc. How will a good suggestion come about unless the OP makes it perfect.Why Support.But the suggestions forum isn't really a place to vote on the OP. If you don't have any new ideas, then technically you shouldn't post (lots of people make this mistake, don't worry). So in a perfect Suggestions forum, a perfect suggestion should have no responses (just bumps, and the Scratch Team saying they accepted/rejected it at the very end)It is qutie obvious, like the OP states, it is weird to remix your own project, and the credit giver doesn't say that you actually owned the original.Support.Why?
・Scratcher1002は「ここにランダムな日本語の言葉はたくさんですか?はい」と言いました・
||||Search:
Topics | Users
||Studios | Projects
||
||||Search:
Topics | Users
||Studios | Projects
||
- jokebookservice1
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
(Quoting the long post above)
Exactly, that is why people are supposed to post, and be constructive when they do.
The voting by itself is not constructive. The other stuff you listed does. How does 100 votes saying “Support” help make the suggestion better? And the suggestion isn't perfect as you said.. it can't be, not until somebody makes a constructive post.
Exactly, that is why people are supposed to post, and be constructive when they do.
The voting by itself is not constructive. The other stuff you listed does. How does 100 votes saying “Support” help make the suggestion better? And the suggestion isn't perfect as you said.. it can't be, not until somebody makes a constructive post.
- Thelnvoker
- Scratcher
100+ posts
The new remix system
Well, there's also a ‘remix tree’ in the right corner of a project where you can view the remixes.
I'm a basically a potato or cat or something with a very dark sense of humor who likes steampunk, traditional art, Skyrim, etc.
Anyone wanna RP with me?
- DownsGameClub
- Scratcher
1000+ posts
The new remix system
Can't we have rebuttals without the support and no support phrases? I am finding the statement contrary since people aren't giving a lot reasons to rebuttal anyway.
Would it only say the new phrase without the notation of credit to the before-remixed project (the 2nd project that user 1 remixed)?
Would it only say the new phrase without the notation of credit to the before-remixed project (the 2nd project that user 1 remixed)?
–DGC
Scratcher since Aug. 2015 +++ Fire Alarm Enthusiast +++ College student studying fire protection engineering