Sheep_maker wrote:

Saiid wrote:

Scratch isn't about getting other people to see your work. It's about learning to code. If all you want if for other people to see your work, then try posting it on social media or something. Scratch is for coding. Not for fame and popularity.

But fame and popularity is one method of encouraging users to keep learning, creating, and challenging themselves.

No. Fame and popularity is one method of encouraging users to cyberbully and spam for attention to try to get famous

Saiid wrote:

Sheep_maker wrote:

Saiid wrote:

Scratch isn't about getting other people to see your work. It's about learning to code. If all you want if for other people to see your work, then try posting it on social media or something. Scratch is for coding. Not for fame and popularity.

But fame and popularity is one method of encouraging users to keep learning, creating, and challenging themselves.

No. Fame and popularity is one method of encouraging users to cyberbully and spam for attention to try to get famous

It's both, honestly.

My idea here was to have it be like the apple app store top charts, so whether it's already frontpaged would be irrelevant. If an app landed in the app store's featured section, that wouldn't mean it gets left off the top charts.

This is a bit confusing, although the central concept is clear. It's obvious that video games will be promoted, but how will Scratch quickly detect which are video games and which are not?

Perhaps a video-game tagging system (similar to the tags we already have for each project already), or people nominate games to be on the page (which in that case, should repeat every two weeks or something)?

Thanks for reading,
Austinato

Guys, I just want to show this

Saiid wrote:

Guys, I just want to show this

Tell me if it doesn't link to an image. It won't let me directly host, even though this site is the top result in google

Scratcher1002 wrote:

pvz_pro wrote:

I'm sure it was removed for a reason, but support anyway.

I don't think it was ever there.

It was their.1

The4thPixel wrote:

pvz_pro wrote:

The4thPixel wrote:

Scratch isn't about popularity, no support.

Then let's remove the show and tell forums and all the front page sections exept scratch news!

That wasn't what I meant, please don't be rude.

I meant that I wanted to tell you to be more constructive when replying, only say that when the suggestion can encorage being popular

pvz_pro wrote:

The4thPixel wrote:

pvz_pro wrote:

The4thPixel wrote:

Scratch isn't about popularity, no support.

Then let's remove the show and tell forums and all the front page sections exept scratch news!

That wasn't what I meant, please don't be rude.

I meant that I wanted to tell you to be more constructive when replying, only say that when the suggestion can encorage being popular

Well it can, because if you read the article, you would know that people can cheat the view system, simply by using something like autoclicker. Also check your spelling.
EDIT: As i have just now tested, autoclicker does not work. However, logging out, clicking the green flag, and logging back in works just fine. Paired with iMacro, it could be a bad thing.

Saiid wrote:

No support

Why?

Im not gonna support this suggestion, because it seems biased to games. What about other projects, like art, programming in general, animations, etc? Are those gonna sink into the depths of Oblivion?

Lythium wrote:

Saiid wrote:

No support

Why?

I've said why, if you read my other posts

Saiid wrote:

Lythium wrote:

Saiid wrote:

No support

Why?

I've said why, if you read my other posts

But it's important to write why on the post where you say don't support, instead of slowly explaining post by post.

Lythium wrote:

Saiid wrote:

Lythium wrote:

Saiid wrote:

No support

Why?

I've said why, if you read my other posts

But it's important to write why on the post where you say don't support, instead of slowly explaining post by post.

I don't really care. I explained my point. Let me be.

Saiid wrote:

Lythium wrote:

Saiid wrote:

Lythium wrote:

Saiid wrote:

No support

Why?

I've said why, if you read my other posts

But it's important to write why on the post where you say don't support, instead of slowly explaining post by post.

I don't really care. I explained my point. Let me be.

K

This had been in Scratch before and it was removed. Here is a Scratch wiki article about it: https://wiki.scratch.mit.edu/wiki/What_the_Community_is_Viewing .

shd02 wrote:

This had been in Scratch before and it was removed. Here is a Scratch wiki article about it: https://wiki.scratch.mit.edu/wiki/What_the_Community_is_Viewing .

i actually edited that a couple days ago to say something about this suggestion lol

Scratcher1002 wrote:

pvz_pro wrote:

I'm sure it was removed for a reason, but support anyway.

I don't think it was ever there.

It was, there's an article on the wiki.

Note: this isn't about what I think of the suggestion. Now you put in the title ‘most viewed games’, so I want to say that scratch isn't just about games
(even though they are the most popular type of project). Scratch is about programming games, animations, simulations, random projects, and so on.

The4thPixel wrote:

Scratch isn't about popularity, no support.

do you even read the stickies?