tiger75 wrote:

I read them in third grade, and they are (if I haven't forgotten) about a bunch of cats who divided themselves into 4 clans, and they fight and are rude to kittypets (cats raised by humans as pets.)

not really… Firepaw (Rusty) was a kittypet and they respected him enough to make him leader. they aren't rude to Ravenpaw (who used to be a warrior and is now a kittypet). they weren't rude to Scourge, they feared him.

tiger75 wrote:

Amethset wrote:

jji10 wrote:

Amethset wrote:

jji10 wrote:

Eh. Depends on your age. If you're under 11, you'll love them. If you're over 11, you'll be neutral about it. If you're over 15, you'll hate it. I'd avoid the 3rd and 4th series unless you REALLY love the first two.

Hmm… interesting. Is it because of the way it's written, or just the subject?

My friend started reading it last month. She's Izzy_The_Kitty, by the way. I'll ask her what she thought of it!

It's sort of a mixture of the two. I mean my brother dislikes it because of the fact that cats don't talk. After all, the older you get, the more skeptical you get of unrealistic animals-talking movies/books.

The way it's written is sort of meh. I don't like the fact that it shows the book from all p.o.v.s which makes huge spoilers and stuff. On top of that, there are annoying mistakes since the writer is Erin Hunter, but there are multiple Erin Hunters writing (book one is made by …, book two is made by … etc). Once, a character made a speech about how proud he was about his daughter, but then the book was replaced by an edited one because his daughter wasn't his daughter lol.

Hmm….. Do you mean that different people named Erin Hunter wrote different books in the series, or different people shared the pen name Erin Hunter?
I like multiple point of views, but everyone's point of view would get kinda confusing…….

Different people write different books, but they all use the name “Erin Hunter” just like the “Rainbow Faries” series by Daisy Meadows. I think 3-5 grade is a good time to start reading them.

WAIT WHAT???!!! SERIOUSLY?!!!!! 0_0

Amethset wrote:

So, lately I've been seeing stuff about the Warriors series. Speedpaints, drawings, general discussions, you name it.

As far as I can tell, it's a series about cats.

So what makes it so good?

And should I read it?

Thanks, everyone!

Well I think the first series is amazing and that you should read it. If you like the first arc you'll probably like the second. The third is pretty horrible though honestly I only read the first and last books in that arc until recently. The fourth is ok. The fifth is pretty good. The sixth well I don't have high hopes. In my option warriors is the kind of series you get crazy hooked on for a while, slowly loose it, slowly get it back, kinda randomly read it constantly and not be interested in it at all.

Amethset wrote:

So, lately I've been seeing stuff about the Warriors series. Speedpaints, drawings, general discussions, you name it.

As far as I can tell, it's a series about cats.

So what makes it so good?

And should I read it?

Thanks, everyone!

You totally should read it, mainly it interested me because of the cat's government and the harshness of their life, if that stuff is interesting to you, read it

WildfiretheSandwing wrote:

Amethset wrote:

So, lately I've been seeing stuff about the Warriors series. Speedpaints, drawings, general discussions, you name it.

As far as I can tell, it's a series about cats.

So what makes it so good?

And should I read it?

Thanks, everyone!

Well I think the first series is amazing and that you should read it. If you like the first arc you'll probably like the second. The third is pretty horrible though honestly I only read the first and last books in that arc until recently. The fourth is ok. The fifth is pretty good. The sixth well I don't have high hopes. In my option warriors is the kind of series you get crazy hooked on for a while, slowly loose it, slowly get it back, kinda randomly read it constantly and not be interested in it at all.

All right!

scratch_happy_cat wrote:

tiger75 wrote:

I read them in third grade, and they are (if I haven't forgotten) about a bunch of cats who divided themselves into 4 clans, and they fight and are rude to kittypets (cats raised by humans as pets.)

not really… Firepaw (Rusty) was a kittypet and they respected him enough to make him leader. they aren't rude to Ravenpaw (who used to be a warrior and is now a kittypet). they weren't rude to Scourge, they feared him.

ahhhhh SPOILERS!!!!!!! XD

Narwhal130 wrote:

Amethset wrote:

So, lately I've been seeing stuff about the Warriors series. Speedpaints, drawings, general discussions, you name it.

As far as I can tell, it's a series about cats.

So what makes it so good?

And should I read it?

Thanks, everyone!

You totally should read it, mainly it interested me because of the cat's government and the harshness of their life, if that stuff is interesting to you, read it

Alright! To the library I go! (as soon as I finish the thirty other books I already have checked out)

scratch_happy_cat wrote:

tiger75 wrote:

Amethset wrote:

jji10 wrote:

Amethset wrote:

jji10 wrote:

Eh. Depends on your age. If you're under 11, you'll love them. If you're over 11, you'll be neutral about it. If you're over 15, you'll hate it. I'd avoid the 3rd and 4th series unless you REALLY love the first two.

Hmm… interesting. Is it because of the way it's written, or just the subject?

My friend started reading it last month. She's Izzy_The_Kitty, by the way. I'll ask her what she thought of it!

It's sort of a mixture of the two. I mean my brother dislikes it because of the fact that cats don't talk. After all, the older you get, the more skeptical you get of unrealistic animals-talking movies/books.

The way it's written is sort of meh. I don't like the fact that it shows the book from all p.o.v.s which makes huge spoilers and stuff. On top of that, there are annoying mistakes since the writer is Erin Hunter, but there are multiple Erin Hunters writing (book one is made by …, book two is made by … etc). Once, a character made a speech about how proud he was about his daughter, but then the book was replaced by an edited one because his daughter wasn't his daughter lol.

Hmm….. Do you mean that different people named Erin Hunter wrote different books in the series, or different people shared the pen name Erin Hunter?
I like multiple point of views, but everyone's point of view would get kinda confusing…….

Different people write different books, but they all use the name “Erin Hunter” just like the “Rainbow Faries” series by Daisy Meadows. I think 3-5 grade is a good time to start reading them.

WAIT WHAT???!!! SERIOUSLY?!!!!! 0_0

Apparently….. POTATOES AND MUSHROOMS I MUST EAT THEY ARE CALLING TO ME I MUST EAT THEM NOW EVEN THOUGH THERE ARE NO POTATOES AND THE MUSHROOMS ARE BREADED AND STILL HOT WOW THAT WAS SO RANDOM

Amethset wrote:

tiger75 wrote:

I read them in third grade, and they are (if I haven't forgotten) about a bunch of cats who divided themselves into 4 clans, and they fight and are rude to kittypets (cats raised by humans as pets.)

Poor kittypets…..

AND KUMQUATS!!!!! YES!!! I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY PERSON WHO KNEW WHAT THOSE WERE!!!!

KUMQUATS!!!!!!!!!

So GOOD!!!!

XD

The kumquat thing is kind of an inside joke on Scratch.

jji10 wrote:

Eh. Depends on your age. If you're under 11, you'll love them. If you're over 11, you'll be neutral about it. If you're over 15, you'll hate it. I'd avoid the 3rd and 4th series unless you REALLY love the first two.

That's really generalized. I'm nineteen and still enjoy the series. Sure, the writing style isn't the best and there are a lot of mistakes, but it's fun when you can look past that.

Lightningstep36 wrote:

Amethset wrote:

tiger75 wrote:

I read them in third grade, and they are (if I haven't forgotten) about a bunch of cats who divided themselves into 4 clans, and they fight and are rude to kittypets (cats raised by humans as pets.)

Poor kittypets…..

AND KUMQUATS!!!!! YES!!! I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY PERSON WHO KNEW WHAT THOSE WERE!!!!

KUMQUATS!!!!!!!!!

So GOOD!!!!

XD

The kumquat thing is kind of an inside joke on Scratch.

Oh. I like to eat kumquats.

I luved the warrior series when I read them(3rd-4th grade) It was like the book I would read. Then when I finished I was like. ._. sooooo what do I do now….. lel. #R.I.P. Firestar

jji10 wrote:

Eh. Depends on your age. If you're under 11, you'll love them. If you're over 11, you'll be neutral about it. If you're over 15, you'll hate it. I'd avoid the 3rd and 4th series unless you REALLY love the first two.

Im thirteen and when i read it I kept thinking about how could it write like this…
like it very much.
i read it on grade one.

LOVE IT SOOOOOOOOO MUCH CINDERPELT OMG