Discuss Scratch

videobob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

I posted a comment on April 19th, and it seemed to have become forgotten. So, I'll repost it:

videobob wrote:

Could you review this game? I made it in 3.5 months, and it's what I believe to be my best work. I would like the Rate & Review, please. Just be careful when you decide to do this. It's a 2 hour long game without previous experience.
Ninja Story 2: Ripped Earth
nprasad
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

videobob wrote:

I posted a comment on April 19th, and it seemed to have become forgotten. So, I'll repost it:

videobob wrote:

Could you review this game? I made it in 3.5 months, and it's what I believe to be my best work. I would like the Rate & Review, please. Just be careful when you decide to do this. It's a 2 hour long game without previous experience.
Ninja Story 2: Ripped Earth
Oh, I'm sorry it was forgotten. Maybe because it's a two hour long game? Wow! I'll rate it an 9, and I'm going to ask for this to be featured. GREAT sound! Nice graphics! I love the intro story! The monsters are cute! My one suggestion is making checkpoints within green field and other areas. Like if the boss kills you, you try again right there with the boss. I LOVE THIS GAME! It's so much fun! It's interesting to pick weapons, too. One other suggestion is making this game two parts so it's not 2 hour long.
JarvisTsui
Scratcher
21 posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

Can you rate my Street Fighter II Tribute Game, please?
Here is the link: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/2240779/
dd21493
Scratcher
2 posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

Rate and Review Game plz! I never get any reviews on my games That's why I'm leaving this comment. Plz rate and review my Survive the night game.

IMPORTANT: You MAY remix IF you leave credit

Plz rate and review this for me it would really help me! Thank you if you did Here is a link https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/84597072/

Last edited by dd21493 (Oct. 25, 2015 16:23:50)

DeltaLimp
Scratcher
65 posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

DeltaLimp wrote:

Rate+Review this Game please: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/84427268/ Thanks
You haven't reviewed it yet…
videobob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

nprasad wrote:

videobob wrote:

I posted a comment on April 19th, and it seemed to have become forgotten. So, I'll repost it:

videobob wrote:

Could you review this game? I made it in 3.5 months, and it's what I believe to be my best work. I would like the Rate & Review, please. Just be careful when you decide to do this. It's a 2 hour long game without previous experience.
Ninja Story 2: Ripped Earth
Oh, I'm sorry it was forgotten. Maybe because it's a two hour long game? Wow! I'll rate it an 9, and I'm going to ask for this to be featured. GREAT sound! Nice graphics! I love the intro story! The monsters are cute! My one suggestion is making checkpoints within green field and other areas. Like if the boss kills you, you try again right there with the boss. I LOVE THIS GAME! It's so much fun! It's interesting to pick weapons, too. One other suggestion is making this game two parts so it's not 2 hour long.
Thanks! I'm currently working on a sequel, that I have a demo out for. There's a password system, so you can start where you last left off if you need to go. Not to mention, I've made the game a bit more organized, as well as adding a new Paint mechanic that lets you enhance your playstyle. If you want to, could you rate and review that? It should be in my signature below.
s-swrichter
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

DeltaLimp wrote:

Rate+Review this Game please: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/84427268/ Thanks

You choose the package: Rate and Review
This is a quality game, with quality graphics but in general it's a bit confusing but It won't count that against your rating. I rate it a 7. I think you should try and get the game curated but featured is a bit to high to aim for… I really liked your test generator. The script in that was really well done. Keep up the good work.
s-swrichter
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

catsruletheworld41 wrote:

can i get the original person to rate and review my project: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/81687308/ it's not a game though so…

You chose the package: Rate and review

Great project, I'll rate it a 5, I love the chalkboard idea, I might do that next year. Maybe add it so they can click which design they want to view? Overall I liked it. Maybe straighten out the lins in the duct tape own other than that I don't have much to say because it's not really a game
tim556688
Scratcher
82 posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

Can you rate and review this
https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/35110224/ ,
thanks.
I already wrote it but nobody has reviewed.
nprasad
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

,

tim556688 wrote:

Can you rate and review this
https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/35110224/ ,
thanks.
I already wrote it but nobody has reviewed.
Hey! Sorry someone forgot about your game. It's really great, i'll rate it 8.5/10. Complicated scripts, nice graphics, dynamic sound. The whole package, in one little game. The only reason I'm not rating it a 10/10 is because it's a tiny bit confusing at the beginning. I like the click ‘h’ and get a help page, but maybe you can add an instructions thing at the beginning. I REALLY like the game, and if it didn't have more than 100 likes, I would suggest it to be featured.
tim556688
Scratcher
82 posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

nprasad wrote:

,

tim556688 wrote:

Can you rate and review this
https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/35110224/ ,
thanks.
I already wrote it but nobody has reviewed.
Hey! Sorry someone forgot about your game. It's really great, i'll rate it 8.5/10. Complicated scripts, nice graphics, dynamic sound. The whole package, in one little game. The only reason I'm not rating it a 10/10 is because it's a tiny bit confusing at the beginning. I like the click ‘h’ and get a help page, but maybe you can add an instructions thing at the beginning. I REALLY like the game, and if it didn't have more than 100 likes, I would suggest it to be featured.

Thank you I already thought about a tutorial, but then i started the work on a new top down shooter.
And about that: “and if it didn't have more than 100 likes, I would suggest it to be featured” , it contains violence so it's NFE and couldn't be featured anyways, but thanks
s-swrichter
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

The famous bump
videobob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

I know I already asked you to review a game, but I'm working on a sequel, and put out a demo. The new game has a much more in-depth story, a password system to start where you left off, and a new “paint” mechanic that lets you enhance your play style. Could you rate + review it if you have the chance? The demo is 5 levels long, so not too much. You can find it in my signature.
s-swrichter
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

videobob wrote:

I know I already asked you to review a game, but I'm working on a sequel, and put out a demo. The new game has a much more in-depth story, a password system to start where you left off, and a new “paint” mechanic that lets you enhance your play style. Could you rate + review it if you have the chance? The demo is 5 levels long, so not too much. You can find it in my signature.

Ok, I'll do it, make sure your following the forum for updates on your review
s-swrichter
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

videobob wrote:

I know I already asked you to review a game, but I'm working on a sequel, and put out a demo. The new game has a much more in-depth story, a password system to start where you left off, and a new “paint” mechanic that lets you enhance your play style. Could you rate + review it if you have the chance? The demo is 5 levels long, so not too much. You can find it in my signature.

You choose: Rate and Review
I liked it I would rate it a 7, congrats! I liked the enemies and the story line. Maybe make a skip button? I also like the password system. It's a really cool feature. The art work is really good except the first monster that came could use some improvement. I suggest checking out Inkscape which is a great professional vector tool, This makes your art look real cool. Overall keep up the good work!
videobob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

s-swrichter wrote:

videobob wrote:

I know I already asked you to review a game, but I'm working on a sequel, and put out a demo. The new game has a much more in-depth story, a password system to start where you left off, and a new “paint” mechanic that lets you enhance your play style. Could you rate + review it if you have the chance? The demo is 5 levels long, so not too much. You can find it in my signature.

You choose: Rate and Review
I liked it I would rate it a 7, congrats! I liked the enemies and the story line. Maybe make a skip button? I also like the password system. It's a really cool feature. The art work is really good except the first monster that came could use some improvement. I suggest checking out Inkscape which is a great professional vector tool, This makes your art look real cool. Overall keep up the good work!
Ok, thanks for the input! Now just a question, did you think the art for the first enemy was poorly done, or did you just not like it's design? Also, just for some extra info about what you thought, could you answer a few questions? Sorry, but I just need the info to make the game as good as possible.
What twists do you expect in the storyline, or do you expect any at all?
Is the paint mechanic something you'd like to see expanded upon?
What do you think of Shroien as a character?
s-swrichter
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

videobob wrote:

s-swrichter wrote:

videobob wrote:

I know I already asked you to review a game, but I'm working on a sequel, and put out a demo. The new game has a much more in-depth story, a password system to start where you left off, and a new “paint” mechanic that lets you enhance your play style. Could you rate + review it if you have the chance? The demo is 5 levels long, so not too much. You can find it in my signature.

You choose: Rate and Review
I liked it I would rate it a 7, congrats! I liked the enemies and the story line. Maybe make a skip button? I also like the password system. It's a really cool feature. The art work is really good except the first monster that came could use some improvement. I suggest checking out Inkscape which is a great professional vector tool, This makes your art look real cool. Overall keep up the good work!
Ok, thanks for the input! Now just a question, did you think the art for the first enemy was poorly done, or did you just not like it's design? Also, just for some extra info about what you thought, could you answer a few questions? Sorry, but I just need the info to make the game as good as possible.
What twists do you expect in the storyline, or do you expect any at all?
Is the paint mechanic something you'd like to see expanded upon?
What do you think of Shroien as a character?

These are all very good questions,

I think the paint mechanic is defently something I'd like you see expand on.

With the first enemy it's not that it's poorly done, it's just compared to the quality of the rest of the game it feels like it could be improved.

I think Shroien is a great character, maybe add some more feelings? He's already really good as a character but it's always good to create a level of depth in your characters so they can relate. It's kinda like writing a book.

I think this game will come far! Probably even front-paged, Good luck!
videobob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

s-swrichter wrote:

videobob wrote:

s-swrichter wrote:

videobob wrote:

I know I already asked you to review a game, but I'm working on a sequel, and put out a demo. The new game has a much more in-depth story, a password system to start where you left off, and a new “paint” mechanic that lets you enhance your play style. Could you rate + review it if you have the chance? The demo is 5 levels long, so not too much. You can find it in my signature.

You choose: Rate and Review
I liked it I would rate it a 7, congrats! I liked the enemies and the story line. Maybe make a skip button? I also like the password system. It's a really cool feature. The art work is really good except the first monster that came could use some improvement. I suggest checking out Inkscape which is a great professional vector tool, This makes your art look real cool. Overall keep up the good work!
Ok, thanks for the input! Now just a question, did you think the art for the first enemy was poorly done, or did you just not like it's design? Also, just for some extra info about what you thought, could you answer a few questions? Sorry, but I just need the info to make the game as good as possible.
What twists do you expect in the storyline, or do you expect any at all?
Is the paint mechanic something you'd like to see expanded upon?
What do you think of Shroien as a character?

These are all very good questions,

I think the paint mechanic is defently something I'd like you see expand on.

With the first enemy it's not that it's poorly done, it's just compared to the quality of the rest of the game it feels like it could be improved.

I think Shroien is a great character, maybe add some more feelings? He's already really good as a character but it's always good to create a level of depth in your characters so they can relate. It's kinda like writing a book.

I think this game will come far! Probably even front-paged, Good luck!
Ok, thank you for the input! I think I see where you're coming from on the first enemy. I just noticed how the outline size was shrunken. I had forgotten to remake the sprite after I shrank the enemy size during development. And about the character development, he will change as the story goes along, and become more in-depth as he discovers things about the world and what's happened to it. Once again, thank you for the insight!
Rainflower4403
Scratcher
100+ posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

Will you rate and review mine? I'd really like some feedback! You might not really understand it if you haven't read the Warriors series, but I still think you could help me. c: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/81197414/#player

Last edited by Rainflower4403 (Nov. 6, 2015 18:50:45)

G_P_U
Scratcher
9 posts

Reviewer's shop (NOW HIRING)

Can you review and rate our game ?
Link is in our signature.
We really appreciate this.

Powered by DjangoBB